THE CHALLENGES OF PUBLIC HEALTH EDUCATION IN INDIA

THE CONTEXT: The 2025 U.S. aid cuts ended $228M in health funding to India, disrupting TB programs (₹58 crore Karnataka project) and HIV care for 2.4 million. Court-backed cuts now risk 6,000–10,000 jobs, worsening India’s health-worker ratio (21/10,000 vs WHO’s 44.5).

IMPACT OF US DECISIONS ON GLOBAL HEALTH

• • WHO Withdrawal (2025):
    • Loss of 15% WHO budget ($420M annual US contribution) threatens HIV/TB programs in Africa and pandemic preparedness via INB.
    • Weakens multilateral frameworks critical for eradicating diseases like smallpox/polio.
  • USAID Defunding (2025):
    • Disrupted $228M (2022) aid to India, affecting:
      • TB Control: Closure of Karnataka Health Promotion Trust’s “Breaking the Barriers” initiative (₹58 crore allocation in 2022-23).
      • HIV/AIDS: Reduced PEPFAR support risking 2.4M Indians on antiretroviral therapy.
      • Environmental Health: Halted Clean Air/Water projects in 12 cities.

INDIA’S PUBLIC HEALTH LANDSCAPE

Constitutional & Historical Context

• • Constitutional Mandate: Article 47 obligates states to prioritize public health, but systemic gaps persist.
  • Education Evolution:
    • Colonial Era (1835): Calcutta Medical College laid the foundations for medical training.
    • Post-1947: NIHFW (1956), PHFI (2006), and NRHM (2005) expanded training but failed to standardize curricula or ensure jobs.

CHALLENGES IN INDIA’S PUBLIC HEALTH ECOSYSTEM:

1. Workforce Crisis: Structural & Policy Paralysis

Constitutional Paradox:

• • • Despite Article 47 (state’s duty to improve public health), only 12% of MPH graduates secure public-sector roles (NHM, NCDC), reflecting systemic neglect of cadre creation.
    • Tamil Nadu’s Epidemic Intelligence Service (2023) absorbed 200 MPH graduates, but Bihar/Jharkhand lack such initiatives, violating constitutional equity (Art 14).

Policy Failures:

• • • NITI Aayog’s 2024 Report: Warned of 6,000–10,000 job losses post-USAID cuts, yet no National Public Health Cadre Act enacted.
    • 15th Finance Commission’s health grants (₹70,000 crore, 2021-26) remain underutilized for workforce expansion.

Private Sector Capture:

• • PMJAY’s ₹6,400 crore/year diversion to private hospitals (NSSO 2024) starves PHCs of funds, prioritizing profit over prevention.
  • Brazil’s Family Health Strategy employs 260,000 community health workers; India’s NHM has only 9,000 ASHA supervisors.

2. Educational Deficits: Regulatory Vacuum & Colonial Hangovers

Regulatory Abandonment:

• • • MCI vs. Dr. Sankalp Bhargava (2022): SC flagged NMC’s exclusion of MPH programs, enabling substandard courses.
    • Katoch Committee (2017): Recommended a National Public Health Education Council; ignored, leading to 40% faculty vacancies (AIIMS data, 2025).

Curriculum Colonization:

• • • Bhore Committee (1946) envisioned preventive care, but 70% MPH syllabi remain hospital-centric, neglecting tribal health or One Health.
    • PASCHIM Banga Khet Mazdoor Samity vs. State of WB (1996) mandated emergency care, but MPH programs lack disaster modules.

Innovation Deficit:

• • • Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (2022) allocated ₹1,500 crore for health-tech, but <10% MPH courses include AI/telemedicine training.

3. Systemic Weaknesses: Fiscal Myopia & Global Dependence

Funding Misalignment:

• • • NHP 2017 Target (2.5% GDP by 2025): Current spending stagnates at 1.1%, lower than Nepal (1.8%) and Sri Lanka (1.9%).
    • Chhattisgarh’s 2024 decision to tax sugary drinks (₹200 crore/year) for public health remains unimplemented nationally.

Foreign Aid Trap:

• • • 2025 USAID cuts ($228M) disrupted Karnataka’s TB program (₹58 crore), exposing over-reliance on volatile grants.

• • • 70% Indian health R&Drelies on EU/US grants, risking sovereignty.

Public-Prunte Sector Asymmetry:

• • • NITI Aayog’s 2023 PPP Index: Gujarat/Maharashtra funnel 65% health CSR funds into private hospitals, sidelining PHCs.
    • Judicial Gap: SC in Devika Biswas vs. Union of India (2016) mandated PHC upgrades, but 60% sub-centers lack antibiotics (NHM-2024).

4. Geopolitical & Sociocultural Blind Spots

Urban-Rural Apartheid:

• • • NFHS-6 (2024): Doctor density in Mumbai (1:900) vs. Bastar (1:22,000), violating Art 21’s right to health.
    • Tribal Health Ignored: PVTGs like Jarawas lack MPH-trained workers; 0 tribal-focused MPH programs exist.

Global Health Marginalization:

• • • WHO South-East Asia Report (2025): India contributes <1% to climate-health research, despite facing 58% of global heatwaves.
    • Rwanda’s Human Resources for Health Program (US-funded) cut maternal mortality by 60%; India’s MMR remains 97/100,000.

Innovative Pathways Forward

• • • Blockchain for Grants: Tamil Nadu’s Health-NFT Pilot (2024) tracks MPH internship funds, reducing leakage by 30%.
    • One Health Cadre: Kerala’s 2024 initiative trains MPH grads in zoonotic disease surveillance, inspired by Kenya’s model.
    • CSR Mandate: Amend Companies Act to allocate 25% health CSR to PHC innovation (NITI Proposal 2025).

THE WAY FORWARD:

 DISRUPTIVE EDUCATION REFORMS

Regulatory Overhaul: Establish a National Public Health Education Council (NPHEC) under NMC, implementing Katoch Committee (2017) recommendations.

• • • Curriculum Revolution: Integrate AI-driven disease surveillance (Kerala’s 2025 One Health Cadre) and tribal health modules (PVTG-focused MPH at AIIMS-Jodhpur).
    • Judicial Mandate: Enforce MCI vs Dr. Sankalp Bhargava (2022) verdict via compulsory 6-month rural residencies, monitored by NPHEC.

Global Benchmarking:

• • • Adopt Rwanda’s Human Resources for Health Program (US-funded), which cut maternal mortality by 60% via MPH-Community Health Worker synergies.

FISCAL ARCHITECTURE REDESIGN

Health Tax Innovation: Introduce 1% GST surcharge (₹12,000 crore/year) for public health R&D, inspired by Mexico’s Soda Tax (reduced diabetes by 12% in 5 years).

• • • CSR Mandate: Amend Companies Act to allocate 25% health CSR (₹8,000 crore/year) to PHC innovation hubs, bypassing private capture (Gujarat’s 2023 PHC-CSR model).

Tech Leverage:

• • • Create Health-NFTs (Tamil Nadu’s 2024 pilot) to crowdsource MPH internship funding, reducing leakage by 30%.

DECENTRALIZED TRAINING ECOSYSTEMS

Geospatial Equity: Establish 5 Regional MPH Institutes (Bihar, Jharkhand, Assam, Manipur, Uttarakhand) via NRHM-PHFI partnerships, mirroring Sri Lanka’s Population-Wise HRH Model (2011).

• • • Tribal Focus: Launch MPH (PVTG Specialization) at TISS Guwahati, addressing Bastar’s 1:22,000 doctor-patient ratio (NFHS-6).

Judicial-Executive Synergy:

• • • Implement PASCHIM Banga Khet Mazdoor Samity vs State of WB (1996) via disaster-ready MPH modules, tested in Kerala’s 2024 flood response.

GLOBAL HEALTH SOVEREIGNTY

South-South Tech Diplomacy: Operationalize WHO-SCTIMST Partnership (2025 MoU) for TB/HIV tech transfers to Africa, generating ₹2,000 crore/year in royalty revenue (HTAP’s Geo-Diversified Licensing Model).

• • • Case Study: Export Kerala’s COVISHIELD Cold Chain Tech (2021) to Malawi, creating 5,000 MPH jobs in vaccine logistics.

Funding Diversification:

• • • Replace USAID gaps with BRICS Health Innovation Fund (₹5,000 crore corpus), leveraging India’s G20 presidency to secure China/Russia contributions.

PRIVATE SECTOR REALIGNMENT

PMJAY Reform: Mandate 50% PMJAY funds for preventive care (e.g., Ayushman Bharat Wellness Centres), enforced via NMC’s Social Accountability Guidelines 2025.

• • • Judicial Push: Use SC’s Vincent Panikulangara vs UoI (1987) to penalize states diverting >30% health funds to private hospitals.

Corporate Accountability:

• • • Launch Public Health Impact Bonds (Karnataka’s 2024 TB bond) where corporations fund MPH salaries in exchange for disease reduction-linked returns.

Constitutional-Judicial Anchor

• • • Enforce Art 21 (Right to Health) via National Health Rights Act 2025, embedding MPH recruitment as fundamental to PHC access (inspired by Costa Rica’s Health as Right Law, 2020).

Data-Driven Governance

• • • Deploy AI-Powered Health Workforce Dashboard (NITI Aayog 2025) tracking real-time MPH employment vs. SDG-3 targets, with penalties for non-compliance under FRBM Act.

THE CONCLUSION:

India must constitutionally embed public health cadres, leveraging innovative fiscal models (1% GST health-tax) and decentralized MPH training hubs, transforming workforce crises into opportunities for health sovereignty and global leadership, as envisioned by NITI Aayog’s Health Vision 2035. Aligning public health education with AI-driven, community-centric models like Kerala’s One Health Cadre can empower India to achieve SDG-3 and uphold Article 21’s promise of universal healthcare.

UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTION:

Q. In a crucial domain like the public healthcare system the Indian State should play a vital role to contain the adverse impact of marketisation of the system. Suggest some measures through which the State can enhance the reach of public healthcare at the grassroots level. 2024

MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:  

Q. “India’s public health education system faces structural and systemic challenges that undermine its potential to address contemporary health crises.” Discuss.

SOURCE:

https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/the-challenges-of-public-health-education-in-india/article69337666.ece#:~:text=There%20is%20an%20urgent%20need,organisations%20engaged%20in%20public%20health.

Spread the Word