THE CONTEXT: India’s decadal Census, delayed by over three years, has sparked widespread concern due to its profound impact on policymaking, resource allocation, and demographic analysis. The consequences of this postponement are far-reaching, affecting everything from social welfare programs to economic planning.
THE ISSUES:
- Reliability of Large-Scale Surveys: The Census provides a foundational framework for large-scale surveys such as the National Family Health Survey and the Periodic Labour Force Survey. These surveys rely on the Census for accurate sampling frames. The delay means these surveys are now based on outdated data from the 2011 Census, compromising their reliability and representativeness.
- Understanding Socio-Economic Changes: The last decade has seen significant transformations in population dynamics, education, occupation, employment, health (especially due to COVID-19), and livelihoods. Without updated census data, it is challenging to accurately assess these changes and their implications for policy and planning.
- Impact on Government Schemes and Development Planning: Government schemes and programs depend heavily on accurate population data for effective implementation and monitoring. The absence of updated Census data makes it difficult to evaluate the coverage and impact of these schemes, potentially leading to inefficient resource allocation and beneficiary exclusion.
- Demographic Transition and Dividend: India is experiencing a rapid demographic transition, which includes changes in age structure, fertility rates, and migration patterns. The Census is crucial for understanding these trends and planning for the resultant demographic dividend. Delaying the Census hampers the ability to make informed decisions in these areas.
- Global and National Statistical Needs: Accurate and up-to-date demographic data are essential for national and global statistical needs. India’s population trends significantly influence global population scenarios. Relying on outdated data or estimates based on past trends can lead to inaccuracies in understanding and planning for future needs.
- Political and Social Implication: The delay has also led to a push for a caste Census, driven more by political motives than developmental needs. While a caste Census could provide valuable data for addressing social inequalities, its primary focus appears to be on political gains rather than a comprehensive understanding of population dynamics. Moreover, the delay in the Census could be seen as a strategic move to avoid revealing inconvenient truths about population growth rates, fertility rates, and the actual impact of government policies.
THE WAY FORWARD:
- Digital and Technological Integration: Implementing digital tools for data collection can expedite the Census process and enhance accuracy. The 2021 Census plans to use mobile applications for data collection, which can work offline and reduce processing time. This approach has been successfully used in other countries, such as the UK and the US, where digital data collection has improved efficiency and reduced costs.
- Decentralized Data Collection: Empowering local administrative units to collect preliminary data can help update demographic information more frequently. This decentralized approach can ensure that data is more current and reflective of local changes. For instance, Canada’s approach involves community and cultural associations in data collection, which enhances data accuracy and relevance.
- Use of Alternative Data Sources: Data from other sources, such as the Registration System for births and deaths and migration data from the National Population Register, can supplement Census data. This approach is particularly useful in countries with significant internal migration, like India. Countries like the Netherlands have successfully integrated administrative data into their Census processes to maintain data accuracy between Census years.
- Public Awareness and Stakeholder Engagement: Increasing public awareness about the importance of the Census and engaging stakeholders from various sectors can improve participation and data quality. The involvement of non-governmental organizations, community groups, and the media can help disseminate information and encourage public cooperation. This strategy has been effective in Canada, where stakeholder involvement is a key component of the Census process.
- Policy and Legislative Reforms: Reforming policies related to Census operations, such as reducing political interference and enhancing transparency, can improve the process’s credibility and efficiency. Establishing independent bodies to oversee Census activities and incorporating feedback from previous exercises can help address operational challenges. The US has considered similar reforms to address issues of undercounting and data accuracy.
THE CONCLUSION:
Conducting the Indian Census without delay is imperative for shaping evidence-based policies and comprehending the nation’s evolving demographic landscape. By implementing innovative solutions and leveraging technology, India can overcome current challenges and establish a more robust, timely, and accurate Census process for the future.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTIONS:
Q.1 Two parallel-run government schemes, viz., the Adhaar Card and NPR, one voluntary and the other compulsory, have led to debates at national levels and litigations. On merits, discuss whether both schemes need to run concurrently. Analyze the potential of the schemes to achieve developmental benefits and equitable growth. 2014
Q.2 Critically examine whether the growing population is the cause of poverty OR poverty is the main cause of population increase in India. 2015
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q.1 The delay in conducting India’s decadal Census has raised concerns about its impact on policymaking and resource allocation. Critically examine the consequences of this delay and suggest measures to mitigate its effects.
SOURCE:
Spread the Word