1. Editorial: Caste and Class – Applying the OBC Creamy Layer Consistently
[The Hindu] | GS-II
Context:
The Hindu’s lead editorial argues that excluding the OBC ‘creamy layer’ is essential but has been applied unevenly. It follows the Supreme Court’s 6 November clarification in the Rohith Nathan matter on civil services candidates denied OBC benefits.
Key Highlights:
- Salary-only test struck down: In Rohith Nathan (March 2026) the SC held that a parent’s salary alone cannot prove social advancement, rejecting DoPT’s 2004 ‘clarification’.
- Who was hurt: From about 2015, dozens of OBC candidates who cleared the CSE lost benefits because pay revisions pushed parental salaries above the limit, even when occupational status had not changed.
- Limits of the ruling: On 6 November the Court clarified that completed selections need not be reopened, after the Centre warned of administrative chaos.
- Editorial’s remedy: Create supernumerary posts for genuine claimants and apply the 1993 equivalence rules to pending allocations, so relief is not limited to those who can afford litigation.
- Uneven gains: OBCs hold about 26.3% of central jobs (DoPT 2024-25) but far less at senior levels, and the Rohini Commission report (2023) on sub-categorisation is still unpublished.
Prelims Corner:
| Term / Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Indra Sawhney (1992) | Upheld 27% OBC quota in central jobs, conditional on excluding the creamy layer; 50% ceiling |
| Creamy layer income limit | Rs 8 lakh per year (revised 2017); salary and agricultural income excluded under 1993 OM |
| Article 16(4) | Enables reservation in public posts for backward classes not adequately represented |
| Article 338B | National Commission for Backward Classes - constitutional status by 102nd Amendment, 2018 |
| Justice G. Rohini Commission | Set up 2017 under Article 340 to examine sub-categorisation of OBCs; report submitted 2023 |
Mains Facts:
| Dimension | Key Points |
|---|---|
| Significance | Keeps reservation focused on those still disadvantaged within OBCs |
| Concerns | Arbitrary DoPT practice, litigation-driven relief, lack of caste-wise socio-economic data |
| Data & Evidence | OBC share in central employment 26.3%, thinning at higher grades |
| Way Forward | Publish Rohini report; use upcoming caste census to collect education, occupation and asset data; transparent equivalence norms |
| Probable Question (GS-II) | The creamy layer principle is essential to the legitimacy of OBC reservation. Discuss in light of recent judicial developments. |