AS MODI MEETS MACRON, THE CHALLENGES THAT THEY WILL NEED TO REFLECT ON

Print

THE CONTEXT: French President Emmanuel Macron’s visit to India aims to strengthen bilateral ties, with the focus not just on ceremonial aspects but on concrete geopolitical and security discussions amidst changing global dynamics, such as the Ukraine conflict, Middle East tensions, and anticipation of potential policy shifts with the possible return of Donald Trump to U.S. presidency. The visit seeks progress on previously established agreements, especially ‘Horizon 2047’ and France’s support to India in Asian deterrence capabilities.

ISSUES:

• Broader implications for regional security: India’s role in European security and France’s support for Indian defense capabilities. Protecting maritime trade in West Asia considering potential changes to US military commitment.
• Regional and International Challenges: The stalled Ukrainian counter-offensive and the renewed debate on European security. Increasing tensions in the Middle East, including the Israel-Hamas conflict and attacks on Red Sea shipping by Houthis, impact the global economy. The potential return of Donald Trump to the White House is causing unease due to his America First policies and implications for international alliances, climate change, and global trade policies.
• US Politics and its global role: The impact of Trump’s possible second term on NATO and European security. India needs to manage the consequences of Trump’s regional and global policies. Reassessment of commitments to climate change and renegotiation terms with allies under Trump’s governance.
• Ideological and Strategic autonomy: The relevance of a multipolar world in the event of American retrenchment from international affairs. The concept of strategic autonomy for India and France in maintaining an independent foreign policy.
• Security and Stability Concerns: There are concerns of bringing peace to Ukraine and establishing a stable security order in Central Europe and India’s contribution to European security amid changing US dynamics. At the same time, there are concerns over France’s role in enhancing India’s defense capabilities to deter war in Asia and strategies to protect Sea Lines of Communication (SLOCs) in West Asian waters if the US reduces its presence.

THE WAY FORWARD:

• Strategic Bilateral Cooperation: Enhance defense cooperation by finalizing pending deals on Rafale Marine aircraft, Scorpene submarines, and technology transfers. Progressively implement the ‘Horizon 2047’ framework with clear benchmarks and timelines to measure advancements.
• Regional Stability and Crisis Management: Engage in diplomatic efforts for conflict resolution in Ukraine, exploring avenues for peaceful negotiation and stabilization in Central Europe. Increase maritime security collaboration between India and France to safeguard critical Sea Lines of Communication (SLOCs).
• Adapting to Global Power Shifts: Assess the impact of potential shifts in US foreign policy and recalibrate India-France strategic priorities accordingly. Foster cooperation between regional powers to form a coordinated approach towards maintaining stability in Eurasia.
• Multilateral Engagement and Climate Action: Strengthen multilateral institutions to ensure a collective response to global challenges such as climate change. Uphold commitments to international climate agreements and initiatives irrespective of changes in US policies.
• Enhancing Economic and Trade Relations: Diversify trade partnerships to mitigate risks from unilateral tariffs and promote open markets. Facilitate technology exchanges and collaborations in emerging green energy and digital innovation sectors.
• Reinforcing Strategic Autonomy: Cultivate independent foreign policies that align with national interests, balancing relations with major powers like the US, Russia, and China. Work towards a multipolar world order that acknowledges various nations’ sovereignty and distinct strategic perspectives.
• Long-term Regional Power Dynamics: Regional powers must address current crises and develop strategies for stabilizing Eurasia and its waters, where the US might reduce its traditional role of ensuring Eurasian security. Protecting maritime trade in West Asia consider potential changes to US military commitment.

THE CONCLUSION:

India and France’s collaboration is crucial for tackling geopolitical challenges in today’s changing global landscape. Strategic discussions and agreements between Delhi and Paris can counter shifts in American foreign policy. It can reinforce the vision of a multipolar world order and ensure regional strength in the face of global uncertainties.

UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTIONS:

Q 1) ‘The time has come for India and Japan to build a strong contemporary relationship involving global and strategic partnerships that will have great significance for Asia and the world.’ Comment. (2019)

Q 2) What introduces friction in the ties between India and the United States is that Washington can still not find a position in its global strategy for India that would satisfy India’s national self-esteem and ambitions. Explain with suitable examples. (2019)

MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:

Q 1) Discuss the evolving regional and international context and its implications for India and France regarding their foreign policy priorities and strategic partnerships.

SOURCE: https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/narendra-modi-emmanuel-macron-meeting-india-france-challenges-9123612/