THE CONTEXT: On 9 June 2025, the Singapore-flagged container vessel MV Wan Hai 503 caught fire 80 km off Kerala, carrying 1,015 containers (157 classed as “dangerous”) and over 2,000 t of fuel. Barely a fortnight earlier, on 25 May 2025, the Liberian-flagged MSC Elsa 3 capsized and sank 13 NM southwest of Kochi with hazardous calcium-carbide cargo, triggering an oil slick and Admiralty litigation. These back-to-back incidents highlight recurring gaps in India’s maritime safety, liability, and pollution response architecture.
THE BACKGROUND:
-
- Maritime centrality: ~95 % of India’s merchandise trade by volume moves by sea; coastal shipping is projected to treble by 2030 under Maritime India Vision 2030.
- Accident uptick: The Directorate General (DG) of Shipping’s Safety Management Report 2024 flags a “steady rise in serious marine casualties inside India’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)”.
- Flags of convenience (FOC) complicate enforcement: Liberia and the Marshall Islands host 33 % of world tonnage yet offer lighter regulation.
GLOSSARY OF KEY TERMS:
-
- Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ): A Sea zone up to 200 NM where a coastal State has sovereign rights for resource exploitation.
- Hazardous and Noxious Substances (HNS): Chemicals that pose a risk to health, safety, or the environment when transported by sea.
- Protection & Indemnity (P&I) Club: Mutual insurance association of shipowners covering third-party liabilities.
- Flag of Convenience (FOC): A State that allows foreign-owned ships to register under its flag with minimal regulatory oversight.
- Nairobi Wreck Removal Convention (2007): Treaty assigning wreck removal responsibility and compulsory insurance to shipowners.
- International Maritime Dangerous Goods (IMDG) Code: IMO code prescribing classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous cargo on ships.
THE THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK:
| Principle | Key instrument | Relevant takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| Flag-State responsibility | United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) Art. 94 | The Flag State must ensure safety, manning, and casualty investigation for every vessel flying its flag. |
| Port-/Coastal-State control | MARPOL, SOLAS, regional MoUs | India, as a coastal State, can detain sub-standard foreign vessels; DG Shipping issues detention orders. |
| Polluter-Pays | International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (MARPOL) & domestic National Oil Spill Disaster Contingency Plan (NOSDCP 2015) | Unlimited liability for environmental damage; claim aggregation via civil courts and marine claims tribunals. |
| No-harm to marine environment | Stockholm (1972), Rio Principles (1992) | Form a constitutional bedrock under Art. 48-A & Art. 21 (expanded right to clean environment). |
WHAT, WHY, HOW OF LIABILITY:
-
- Bill of Lading (BoL): A negotiable contract evidencing carriage; holder has title to cargo. Loss/damage compensation flows to BoL holder.
- Protection & Indemnity (P&I) Clubs: Not-for-profit mutual insurers that pool risk for shipowners—cover third-party liabilities including cargo, crew, wreck removal, and pollution.
- Limitation of liability: Capped by the Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims (LLMC 1996), but no cap for oil or HNS pollution—hence escalating coastal claims after MSC Elsa 3.
- Wreck removal: Nairobi International Convention on the Removal of Wrecks (2007)—India acceded in 2019; owner must mark, remove or pay for wrecks within 200 NM.
TECHNICAL & SAFETY SPECIFICATIONS:
-
- SOLAS (Safety of Life at Sea)—born out of the 1912 Titanic disaster; today mandates lifeboats on each side sufficient for 100 % persons-on-board, weekly abandon-ship drills and fire-bulkhead standards.
- ISM Code (International Safety Management) & ISPS Code (International Ship and Port Facility Security) embed audit-driven safety culture.
- Stowage codes under the International Maritime Dangerous Goods (IMDG) Code classify calcium carbide (MSC Elsa 3) and explosives (Wan Hai 503) as Class 4.3 and Class 1, respectively, requiring segregated holds and temperature monitoring, reportedly violated in both cases.
THE SIGNIFICANCE:
-
- Ecological: Kerala’s Beypore–Kollam stretch houses critical olive-ridley nesting sites and artisanal fisheries; HNS leakage risks trophic bioaccumulation.
- Economic: Cochin Port handles 12 % of India’s containerised coastal cargo—temporary anchorage restrictions have already inflated freight rates by ~8 %.
- Security: Stricken vessels drifting towards offshore gas platforms illustrate “brown-to-blue” interface vulnerability, echoing DG Shipping’s 2024 PSC-FSI report.
DRIVERS BEHIND RISING INCIDENTS:
-
- Aging feeder fleet: median age 21 years in Indian near-coastal trade (global average 14 years).
- Flag-state regulatory arbitrage: FOC registers relax inspection cycles.
- Extreme weather volatility in Arabian Sea (RIMES data show 27 % rise in high-sea state days, 2010-24).
- Crew fatigue & connectivity bias—Wakashio-type “sail close to shore for cell signal” behaviour.
- Cargo mis-declaration—explosives on Wan Hai 503 not listed among the dangerous goods manifests.
INDIAN POLICY & INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK:
-
- Merchant Shipping Act 1958 (multiple amendments) plus Merchant Shipping (Wrecks and Salvage) Rules 1974—being overhauled by the Merchant Shipping Bill 2024, which embeds Nairobi-style compulsory wreck-removal insurance and higher penalties.
- National Oil Spill Disaster Contingency Plan, and National Marine Oil Spill & Chemical Emergency Response Exercise “Sagar Aaraksha” series.
- Sagarmala and Gati Shakti logistics corridors include ₹ 2,600 cr for Vessel Traffic Management & Information Systems (VTMIS) coverage by 2027.
- Blue Economy Policy Draft 2021—targets “zero-spill coastal cluster” and indigenous salvage industry by 2030.
GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE & BEST PRACTICES:
| Country / Body | Notable Practice | Insight |
|---|---|---|
| European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA) | CleanSeaNet satellite oil-spill detection, 10-min alerts to littoral States | Demonstrates the value of regional agency pooling of technical resources. |
| China | Compulsory HNS Fund (2011) for near-coastal spills; salvage fleet rated “IMO Tier 3” | Model for India’s Sagarmala-linked Green Maritime Fund. |
| IMO | Casualty Investigation Code (mandatory since 2010) emphasises human-factor analysis. | Periodic feedback loop converts accident ‘lessons learned’ into SOLAS, MARPOL amendments. |
THE ISSUES:
-
- Ratification Gap: India has not ratified 2010 HNS Convention or 2004 Ballast Water Convention; claims and invasive-species costs remain externalised.
- Fragmented Jurisdiction: DG Shipping (MoPSW), Coast Guard (MoD) and MOES institutes run parallel databases—no single incident command.
- Limited Salvage Capacity: Only three ocean-going salvage tugs under Indian flag; Offshore Warrior had to refuel mid-mission.
- Protracted Litigation: Admiralty courts understaffed; BoL holders wait years while perishable coastal livelihoods suffer.
- Data Opacity: GISIS access restrictions hamper academia-policy interface; domestic casualty statistics lag 12-18 months.
- Port Infrastructure Deficits: Only two Indian ports comply fully with IMO Safe Mooring guidelines (FAL 49/22); hazardous-cargo berths lack dedicated foam systems.
THE WAY FORWARD:
-
- Ratify HNS & Ballast Conventions: Parliament should fast-track the Merchant Shipping Bill 2024 schedule, enabling automatic domestic application and activation of international compensation funds within two years.
- Ring-fenced Salvage Fund: Levy a ₹0.50-per-GT “Marine Safety Cess” on all port calls to capitalise a ₹1 500 cr fund for indigenous Tier-1 salvage tugs and deep-submergence ROVs.
- Unified Maritime Incident Command (UMIC): Merge DG Shipping casualty cell, ICG pollution-response HQ and MOES’s INCOIS into a joint UMIC with statutory powers under Disaster Management Act 2005.
- Dynamic Risk Mapping: Integrate AIS, VTMIS and INS Sagarmala satellite feeds to produce 6-hourly predictive drift models public on an Open-Data dashboard, boosting fisher community preparedness.
- Fast-track Admiralty Benches: Notify at least one Admiralty bench in every coastal High Court with 180-day disposal target, supported by e-BoL blockchain evidence to shorten compensation cycles.
- Mandatory “Cargo DNA” Declarations: DG Shipping circular mandating QR-coded cargo manifests linked to Customs ICEGATE to curb mis-declaration of hazardous goods.
- Community Contingency Contracts: Coastal District Magistrates to pre-contract fishing cooperatives for debris recovery with assured wage-loss compensation, fostering “whole-of-society” response.
- Green-Port Upgrades: Use PM-Gati Shakti to co-finance fixed-foam systems and emergency towing gear at all Major Ports by 2027, tied to PPP tariff incentives.
- Seafarer Digital-Wellness Codes: Amend ISM compliance audits to include connectivity solutions (on-board Wi-Fi, mental-health rotations) to deter risky “signal-seeking” coastal deviations.
THE CONCLUSION:
The twin Kerala accidents are a wake-up call: without swift legislative ratifications, indigenous salvage build-up and a unified command architecture, India’s aspiration to be a “maritime power with ecological conscience” may founder on its shores.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTION:
Q. What is oil pollution? What are its impacts on the marine ecosystem? In what way is oil pollution particularly harmful for a country like India? 2023
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q. Critically examine the adequacy of India’s legal-institutional framework for maritime casualty response and environmental liability. Suggest reforms to align domestic law with emerging global conventions.
SOURCE:
Spread the Word