THE CONTEXT: The 1960 Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), brokered by the World Bank, has long served as a cornerstone for water-sharing between India and Pakistan. However, persistent disputes and the growing impacts of climate change necessitate urgent amendments to ensure sustainable management of the Indus River Basin. Recent calls for treaty modifications underscore the need for a more holistic and ecologically integrated approach to transboundary water governance.
THE ISSUES:
- Dispute Resolution Mechanism: India has expressed dissatisfaction with the current dispute resolution process under the IWT, accusing Pakistan of intransigence and material breaches of the treaty. Pakistan’s decision to bypass the treaty-compliant Neutral Expert proceedings and seek arbitration at The Hague over India’s Kishenganga and Ratle hydroelectric projects has further complicated matters.
- Climate Change Impacts: Climate change has significantly altered the hydrology of the Indus basin. The basin relies heavily on glaciers and snow melts, which are increasingly impacted by climate change, leading to more volatile and seasonal flows. The 2015 NASA ranking of the Indus Basin as the world’s second most over-stressed aquifer underscores the urgency of addressing these changes within the treaty framework.
- Water Quality and Population Pressures: The Indus River is crucial for India and Pakistan’s agricultural output and GDP, especially Pakistan, where it accounts for over 90% of agricultural production and 25% of GDP. The growing population and deteriorating water quality threaten food and nutritional security, human health, and biodiversity. Effective management of these issues is essential for the sustainability of the basin.
- Infrastructure Development and Downstream Impacts: Contentions often arise over the perceived impacts of infrastructure development, such as dams and hydroelectric projects, on downstream flows. Pakistan, as the lower riparian state, frequently raises concerns about India’s projects, which it claims undermine its water security. This issue is exacerbated by a significant trust deficit between the two nations.
- Need for Holistic Basin Management: There is a pressing need to move beyond the insular approach of partitioning the Indus River system and adopt a holistic basin management strategy. This includes integrating ecological perspectives into treaty governance, institutionalizing Environmental Flows (EF), and harmonizing these with international principles such as those in the UN Watercourses Convention. A robust, World Bank-supervised data-sharing framework would enhance accountability and help develop effective mitigation and adaptation strategies.
THE WAY FORWARD:
- Integrating Climate Change Data and Real-Time Monitoring: Establish a legally binding, World Bank-supervised framework for real-time data-sharing on climate change impacts, water quality, and flow magnitudes.
- Institutionalizing Environmental Flows (EFs): Amend the treaty to include provisions for Environmental Flows (EFs) to sustain aquatic ecosystems and support human livelihoods.
- Enhancing Dispute Resolution Mechanisms: Reform the dispute resolution process to include a more flexible and transparent mechanism, possibly integrating both Court of Arbitration and Neutral Expert proceedings.
- Promoting Sustainable Basin Management: Shift the focus from mere river management to holistic basin management, prioritizing sustainability and equitable resource distribution.
- Building Trust and Enhancing Cooperation: Facilitate regular dialogue and cooperation between India and Pakistan, involving multiple stakeholders, including non-state actors, to build trust and develop joint water management strategies.
THE CONCLUSION:
Amending the IWT to incorporate climate change considerations and enhance data-sharing mechanisms is crucial for the treaty’s relevance in the 21st century. By prioritizing environmental flows and collaborative basin management, India and Pakistan can transform the IWT into a model for global transboundary water cooperation. Such reforms would mitigate conflicts and promote sustainable development and resilience against climate-induced water variability.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTIONS:
Q.1 Dam failures are always catastrophic, especially downstream, resulting in a colossal loss of life and property. Analyze the various causes of dam failures. Give two examples of significant dam failures. 2023
Q.2 The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has predicted a global sea level rise of about one meter by AD 2100. What would be its impact in India and the other countries in the Indian Ocean region? 2023
Q.3 Climate Change is a global problem. How India will be affected by climate change? How will the Himalayan and coastal states of India be affected by climate change? 2017
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q.1 Discuss the key provisions of the IWT, the current issues surrounding its implementation, and suggest measures to address these challenges while ensuring sustainable water management in the Indus basin.
SOURCE:
Spread the Word