THE CONTEXT: The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) is set to conduct the second test flight of the uncrewed Gaganyaan mission, marking a significant milestone in India’s space exploration endeavors.
EXPLANATION:
The mission is part of ISRO’s ambitious human spaceflight program aimed at demonstrating India’s capability for human spaceflight.
Gaganyaan Mission
The Gaganyaan project aims to showcase India’s prowess in human spaceflight by sending a three-person crew into a 400-kilometer orbit for a three-day trip before safely returning them to Earth by landing in the Indian Ocean seas.
ISRO Chairman S Somanath announced that the second test flight of the uncrewed Gaganyaan mission is scheduled for April 24.
Additionally, the project involves further trials, including a test vehicle flight mission and an airdrop test, to be conducted later this year.
Following the uncrewed test flights, ISRO plans to conduct two more uncrewed missions next year.
If all goes according to plan, the manned mission is expected to take place by the end of next year, marking a significant milestone for India’s space program.
Significance of Gaganyaan Mission
Global Spacefaring Nation: Successful completion of the Gaganyaan mission will elevate India to the ranks of leading spacefaring nations, including the United States, Russia, and China, which have active human spaceflight programs.
Indigenous Technology Stack:ISRO’s human spaceflight program is distinguished by its reliance on indigenous technology, with ISRO working closely with partner vendors to develop a fully indigenous technology stack for Gaganyaan’s space infrastructure. This sets India apart from countries like the US, which often contracts private firms for such projects.
Gaganyaan and India’s Position in the Global Space Ecosystem
India’s success in space exploration is further exemplified by its Chandrayaan missions, which have made significant observations regarding the presence of water on the lunar surface, contributing to applied research projects in space.
Through Gaganyaan and other space missions, India is expected to enhance its stature in applied research projects in space, solidifying its position in the global space ecosystem.
THE CONTEXT: As the current Union government completes two terms, one of its flagship programmes was Housing For All (HfA) by 2022, both in urban and rural areas, planned under the PMAY (Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana) scheme in 2015.
The two basic components of the scheme are Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (Urban) (PMAY-U) for the urban poor and Pradhan Mantri Awaas Yojana (Gramin) (PMAY-G or PMAY-R ) for the rural poor.
It encompasses both urban and rural areas, with a focus on addressing the housing needs of economically weaker sections and low-income groups.
Under PMAY, various verticals are designed to cater to different segments of the population, including in-situ slum redevelopment, affordable housing partnerships, and beneficiary-led construction.
Objectives of the PMAY Scheme are:
Rehabilitation of Slum Dwellers: One of the primary objectives of PMAY is to rehabilitate slum dwellers by involving private developers in the process.
Promotion of Affordable Housing: PMAY aims to promote affordable housing for weaker sections through Credit Linked Subsidy Schemes (CLSS) and partnerships with public and private sectors.
In-Situ Slum Redevelopment (ISSR): The scheme targets the redevelopment of slums in their existing locations to provide better housing conditions for residents.
Subsidy for Beneficiary-led Construction (BLC): PMAY provides subsidies to beneficiaries for constructing their own houses.
Performance of the PMAY Scheme
Despite the initial target of achieving “Housing for All” by 2022, the scheme has faced challenges in implementation and has been extended until December 31, 2024.
However, the progress has been inadequate, with significant shortfalls in the number of houses constructed compared to the actual demand.
The scheme has fallen short of its objectives, with an estimated shortage of around 20 million houses in rural areas and three million in urban centers.
The in-situ slum redevelopment (ISSR) vertical, which addresses a critical need in cities, has particularly underperformed, with only a fraction of the sanctioned houses completed.
Several factors contribute to the challenges faced by PMAY, including land acquisition issues, inadequate community involvement in planning, and discrepancies between city master plans and PMAY objectives.
Additionally, reliance on large capital-intensive solutions and limited government contribution to investment expenditure pose significant hurdles.
Private Sector Participation in Social Housing
Role of the Private Sector:
The PMAY scheme relies on private sector participation to bridge the gap in social housing.
However, the success of private sector involvement has been mixed, with some projects failing to address the needs of slum dwellers effectively.
Challenges in Private Sector Participation:
Issues such as vertical growth leading to increased utility costs, inadequate housing design, and land ownership complexities have hampered the effectiveness of private sector participation.
Moreover, the dichotomy between city master plans and PMAY objectives further complicates private sector engagement in social housing initiatives.
Financial Contribution:
While the private sector plays a role in PMAY, the bulk of the financial burden falls on beneficiary households, highlighting the need for greater government investment and support.
THE CONTEXT: On Earth Day, NABARD unveiled its Climate Strategy 2030 document, aiming to address India’s pressing need for green financing.
EXPLANATION:
The initiative acknowledges the significant shortfall in green finance inflows, with only $49 billion garnered annually against the required $170 billion to achieve India’s climate goals by 2030.
Challenges and Focus Areas:
The strategy identifies key challenges, particularly the lack of private sector engagement in adaptation and resilience efforts due to perceived bankability and commercial viability issues.
To overcome these challenges, NABARD’s Climate Strategy 2030 is structured around four pillars: accelerating green lending across sectors, playing a broader market-making role, internal green transformation, and strategic resource mobilization.
Sustainable Practices in Real Estate Development
DLF, a leading real estate developer, highlights its sustainable construction initiatives, including zero-discharge water systems and sewage treatment plants.
By recycling millions of liters of water daily and prioritizing greenery preservation, DLF exemplifies a commitment to environmental, social, and governance excellence, as evidenced by its inclusion in the Dow Jones Sustainability Index.
Signature Global (India) Ltd. emphasizes its commitment to sustainability through EDGE certification and IGBC gold ratings for its projects.
The company implements water-saving practices such as low-flow faucets and rainwater harvesting systems to reduce water usage by 52%.
By integrating these techniques into its developments, Signature Global aims to enhance urban water system resilience while conserving natural resources.
Emphasis on Sustainability and Economic Benefits
Real estate developers underscore the economic benefits of sustainable practices, including energy and cost savings for homeowners.
By emphasizing self-regulation and behavioral changes among workers, the industry aims to address environmental challenges comprehensively and promote sustainability within the construction sector.
Recognition of Environmental Excellence
Remsons Industries Ltd., an auto ancillary manufacturer, received a Gold Medal in the Ecovadis Sustainability Assessment, placing it among the top 5% of evaluated companies globally.
The recognition reaffirms the company’s commitment to environmental stewardship, social responsibility, and corporate ethics.
Remsons Industries’ exemplary performance in key areas such as environment, labor rights, and ethics underscores its dedication to sustainability and ESG excellence.
Corporate Commitment to Sustainability
Executive Director of Remsons Industries emphasizes sustainability as a core value ingrained in the company’s ethos.
The company remains committed to developing environmentally responsible products while upholding social responsibility standards throughout its supply chain.
Remsons Industries’ Gold Medal achievement reflects its dedication to promoting environmental conservation and social welfare through sustainable business practices.
National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD):
NABARD is a development bank focusing primarily on the rural sector of the country.
It is the apex banking institution to provides finance for Agriculture and rural development.
Its headquarter is located in Mumbai, the country’s financial capital.
It is responsible for the development of small industries, cottage industries, and any other such village or rural projects.
It is a statutory body established in 1982 under Parliamentary act-National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development Act, 1981.
THE CONTEXT: Recent research conducted at the Institute of Molecular Virology at Ulm University Medical Centre, Germany, sheds light on a novel defense mechanism employed by the human body to inhibit viral transmission via non-conventional routes.
EXPLANATION:
Published in Nature Microbiology, the study reveals the role of extracellular vesicles in bodily fluids, such as saliva and semen, in inhibiting viral infection.
Extracellular Vesicles as Defense Agents
Extracellular vesicles, small structures enclosed by fat, play a crucial role in intercellular communication and substance transport.
The researchers found that these vesicles are abundant in saliva and semen and contain PS proteins on their surfaces, similar to those exploited by viruses for entry.
Through a series of experiments, they demonstrated that these vesicles compete with viruses for entry receptors, thereby impeding viral infection.
Implications of the Discovery
The study’s findings extend beyond Zika virus to encompass other viruses that utilize the PS receptor for entry, including dengue, chikungunya, West Nile, ebola, and vesicular stomatitis viruses.
Importantly, viruses that do not utilize the PS receptor, such as HIV and SARS-CoV-2, remain unaffected by the presence of extracellular vesicles.
This discovery represents a significant advancement in our understanding of host defense mechanisms against viral infections.
Viruses:
Viruses, such as Zika, dengue, and chikungunya, are adept at transmitting themselves from host to host, a crucial aspect of their life cycle.
Achieving successful transmission is a complex interplay between the virus and the host’s immune system.
For a virus to successfully infect a new host, it must first gain access to target cells, a process known as tropism.
Tropism is driven by specific interactions between viral surface proteins and receptors on host cells.
These receptors are typically highly selective, dictating which cells the virus can infect.
For instance, HIV targets cells expressing the CD4 protein, while SARS-CoV-2 uses the ACE2 receptor for entry.
One such receptor of interest is phosphatidyl serine (PS), typically expressed by dying cells in the body.
PS acts as a signal for immune cells to initiate the clearance of these dying cells.
However, viruses have evolved a strategy known as apoptotic mimicry, wherein they express PS on their own surfaces.
By doing so, viruses can exploit the PS pathway to infect host cells, effectively hijacking the immune response for their benefit.
Challenges in Studying Viral Transmission
Studying viral transmission presents significant challenges, particularly when viruses utilize receptors like PS for entry.
These receptors are often expressed by various cell types, complicating the understanding of transmission routes.
Additionally, the mere presence of a virus in a bodily fluid does not guarantee transmission through that route.
For example, although Zika virus can be detected in saliva, semen, and breast milk, it primarily spreads via mosquitoes rather than orally or sexually.
Future Directions and Speculations
While the therapeutic implications of this discovery are yet to be fully realized, it opens up new avenues for research into potential antiviral strategies.
Furthermore, the study raises intriguing questions about the evolutionary dynamics between viruses and their hosts.
The notion that PS-containing vesicles in humans may have influenced the evolution of mosquito-borne viruses presents a thought-provoking avenue for further investigation.
THE CONTEXT: The Supreme Court of India delivered a verdict in the Association of Democratic Reforms vs. Election Commission of India, addressing the petitioner’s demands to return to paper ballots and 100% vote verification through VVPAT slips. The court rejected these demands, emphasizing the need for a balanced perspective on the electoral system and cautioning against undue skepticism that could hinder progress.
ISSUES:
Rejection of Pleas for Paper Ballots and Full VVPAT Verification: The Supreme Court bench, comprising Justices Sanjiv Khanna and Dipankar Datta, unequivocally rejected the petitioner’s pleas for a return to paper ballots, the issuance of printed paper ballots to each voter to be placed in a ballot box and counted in total, and the counting of every vote through a Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) slip, which would have amounted to 100% verification of votes.
Interventions to Enhance Trust in the Voting System: Despite rejecting the pleas, the Court issued two significant directions to enhance the transparency and credibility of the voting process. The first direction mandates that Symbol Uploading Units (SULs) be kept in a substantial room for 45 days after election results are declared for examination and scrutiny. The second direction allows candidates who finish in second or third place to request a check of EVMs in their constituency, with 5% of machines per assembly segment to be examined.
Maintaining a Balanced Perspective: The verdict emphasized the importance of maintaining a balanced perspective when evaluating systems or institutions and cautioned against blind distrust, which can lead to unwarranted skepticism and hinder progress.
Affirmation of the Current Voting System: Justice Datta, in his judgment, stated that the question of returning to ballot papers does not arise, as the current electronic voting system has no significant flaws and has received global acclaim.
Unnecessary Criticism of the Petitioner’s Intentions: Justice Datta’s suggestion that the petitioner’s intentions might be malicious or an attempt to undermine the nation’s accomplishments was unnecessary and avoidable. The petitioner, Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR), has a history of monitoring the electoral process and raising legitimate concerns.
Election Commission’s Efforts to Assuage Concerns: The Election Commission of India has consistently addressed EVMs through hackathons and introduced the VVPAT system in 2012 to ensure a paper trail for verifying the electronic vote.
THE WAY FORWARD:
Enhanced Transparency with Symbol Loading Units (SLUs): The Court’s directive to seal and store SLUs in a substantial room for 45 days post-elections allow for a period during which these units can be scrutinized if necessary. This measure adds a layer of transparency to the process, ensuring that the symbols loaded into the EVMs are the ones that were intended and used during the election.
Provision for Candidate-Requested EVM Examination: Allowing candidates in second or third place to request the examination of 5% of EVMs per assembly segment provides a formal mechanism for addressing concerns about the vote count. This process should be communicated to all candidates and parties to ensure they know their rights and procedures.
Exploration of Technological Advancements: Justice Khanna’s suggestion that the Election Commission consider using electronic machines to count paper slips and barcodes should be taken seriously. The EC should conduct feasibility studies and pilot projects to assess these technologies’ practicality and potential benefits.
Continued Public Education and Outreach: The Election Commission should continue educating the public about the EVM and VVPAT systems. This could include more hackathons, public demonstrations, and informational campaigns to build trust and understanding among voters.
Regular System Audits and Upgrades: Independent experts can conduct regular EVM and VVPAT systems audits to help identify and address potential vulnerabilities. Additionally, the EC should stay abreast of technological advancements and upgrade systems as necessary to maintain the highest standards of election integrity.
Strengthening Legal Frameworks: The legal frameworks governing the use of EVMs and VVPATs should be reviewed and strengthened to ensure they are robust and capable of addressing emerging challenges.
Addressing Concerns Constructively: While skepticism about the electoral process can be healthy, it is essential to address such concerns constructively. The EC and the judiciary should remain open to legitimate inquiries and criticisms and respond in a manner that reinforces the credibility of the electoral system.
THE CONCLUSION:
The Supreme Court’s decision reaffirmed the credibility of India’s electronic voting system and introduced additional measures for vote verification to enhance trust. The ruling underscored the importance of maintaining confidence in the electoral process, which is crucial for the functioning of democracy. It highlighted the ongoing efforts to address concerns about the voting system through technological and procedural safeguards.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTIONS:
Q.1 Discuss the role of the Election Commission of India, considering the evolution of the Model Code of Conduct. 2022
Q.2 Considering the recent controversy regarding the use of Electronic Voting Machines (EVM), what are the challenges before the Election Commission of India to ensure the trustworthiness of elections in India? 2018
Q.3 To enhance the quality of democracy in India, the Election Commission of India has proposed electoral reforms in 2016. What are the suggested reforms, and how significant are they in making democracy successful? 2017
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q.1 Evaluate the implications of the Supreme Court’s recent directives on using Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) and Voter-Verified Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) systems to enhance the transparency and credibility of elections in India. Discuss the role of judicial interventions in maintaining the integrity of electoral processes.
THE CONTEXT: The Green Credit Program, introduced by India’s Environment Ministry, incentivizes environmental restoration through market-based mechanisms. Critics argue it may bypass existing conservation laws, focusing narrowly on tree planting without considering broader ecosystem impacts. The program aims to restore degraded forest land but raises concerns about promoting monocultures and overlooking the complexity of forest ecosystems.
ISSUES:
Incentive Structure and Implementation: The Green Credit Program is a market-based incentive mechanism to promote environmental restoration, including afforestation and water conservation. However, the effectiveness of these incentives depends significantly on how they are implemented on the ground and whether the implementers have a deep understanding of local ecological challenges.
Potential for Negative Ecological Impacts: There is a concern that the program could lead to ecological damage, such as promoting monocultures or inappropriate vegetation, which might not suit the local environment. This could potentially harm biodiversity and disrupt local ecosystems.
Complexity in Measuring Environmental Impact: The program aims to quantify environmental benefits, such as carbon sequestration or biodiversity improvement, which are inherently complex to measure. This complexity could lead to challenges in accurately assessing the impact of green credits and ensuring that they contribute positively to environmental goals.
Integration with Existing Environmental Laws: The Green Credit Program might conflict with environmental regulations, particularly the Forest Conservation Act. The program might bypass some of the stringent requirements of forest conservation, thus weakening overall ecological governance.
Market Dynamics and Fungibility Issues: The market-based approach raises issues about the fungibility of green credits. Different environmental credits (e.g., for water conservation, biodiversity, or carbon sequestration) may not be readily comparable or tradable on a single platform, complicating the market dynamics.
Impact on Mandatory Compliance and Environmental Laws: The program could influence how industries comply with mandatory environmental regulations. Allowing industries to use green credits to expedite the forest clearance process might undermine the thorough assessment and mitigation strategies required under environmental law.
THE WAY FORWARD:
Incentivizing Biodiversity and Local Species Conservation: Establish guidelines prioritizing planting native and diverse species over monocultures. This would help maintain the ecological balance and support local wildlife. Set up robust monitoring systems to ensure that the green credits are awarded for actions that genuinely contribute to biodiversity conservation.
Engage Local Communities: Involve local communities in the planning and implementing afforestation projects to leverage their traditional ecological knowledge and ensure the selection of appropriate species.
Conduct Ecological Assessments: Before any plantation activity, conduct thorough ecological assessments to understand the specific needs of the area and to plan plantations that enhance, rather than disrupt, local ecosystems.
Adopt Ecological Restoration Practices: Encourage ecological restoration practices that focus on allowing natural regeneration, which can be more effective and less invasive than planting trees.
Standardize Measurement Methods: Develop standardized methods for measuring the environmental impact of various actions to ensure that credits reflect real, quantifiable benefits.
Ensure Fungibility: Work towards creating a system where different environmental credits (e.g., biodiversity, water conservation) can be traded on a common platform, possibly by establishing conversion factors that reflect their relative ecological value.
Harmonize with Existing Laws: Amend the Green Credit Program guidelines to ensure they complement rather than conflict with existing environmental regulations. Clearly define terms such as “forest” and “degraded forest” within the program to prevent misclassification and ensure that the program supports the objectives of existing laws.
THE CONCLUSION:
The Green Credit Program’s market-based approach to forest restoration is challenged by fungibility issues and compliance with environmental laws. Experts fear it may conflict with the Forest Conservation Act and simplify complex ecological considerations to facilitate industrial growth. The program’s success hinges on balancing economic incentives with the preservation of biodiversity and adherence to environmental principles.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTIONS:
Q.1 Should the pursuit of carbon credit and clean development mechanisms set up under UNFCCC be maintained even though there has been a massive slide in the value of carbon credit? Discuss India’s energy needs for economic growth. 2014
Q.2 How does the draft Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2020, differ from EIA Notification, 2006? 2020
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q.1 Critically analyze the effectiveness of the Green Credit Program as a tool for environmental and ecological restoration in India. Discuss the potential benefits and drawbacks of implementing such a market-based incentive mechanism, particularly in forest conservation and biodiversity.
THE CONTEXT: The National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) launched by the Indian government in 2019, aimed at reducing particulate matter in the air by 20-30% by 2024 from 2017 levels, later revised to 40% by 2026. It highlights the challenges in implementing the Clean Air Action Plans (CAAPs) due to inconsistent fund utilization, bureaucratic delays, and lack of effective standard operating procedures. It emphasizes the importance of Emissions Inventory (EI), Air Quality (AQ) modeling, and Source Apportionment (SA) studies in identifying pollution sources and formulating targeted strategies.
ISSUES:
Inconsistent Implementation of Clean Air Action Plans (CAAPs): While most cities have submitted their CAAPs, the implementation has been inconsistent. On average, only 60% of the allocated funds have been utilized, with some cities like Visakhapatnam and Bengaluru spending almost none of their designated budgets.
Delays in Implementation: There are significant delays in implementing NCAP, often due to slow approvals from competent authorities. These delays are related to technical specifications, tendering processes, and procurement of necessary products like mechanical sweepers and electric buses.
Lack of Standard Operating Procedures: The absence of well-defined standard operating procedures for the implementation process contributes to delays. The lack of clear timelines and bureaucratic hurdles further exacerbate these issues.
Doubts About Effectiveness of Mitigation Measures: Recent findings questioning the efficacy of specific mitigation measures, such as outdoor smog towers, have led to hesitation among decision-makers regarding adopting proposed solutions.
Challenges in Pollution Source Identification: SA studies, while helpful, cannot predict future emissions and require substantial resources. They also struggle to distinguish between pollution sources that are close together due to similar chemical signatures.
Limited Use of Air Quality Modeling: Air Quality modeling, which can help understand pollution dispersion from distant sources, is not being fully exploited to inform mitigation strategies.
Focus on Primary PM Emissions Only: Many control measures focus solely on primary particulate matter emissions, neglecting secondary precursors, also significant contributors to air pollution.
Lack of Comprehensive Infrastructure: Apart from a few cities like Delhi, Pune, Mumbai, and Ahmedabad, most do not have the necessary decision-support systems to forecast and manage air quality effectively.
Expand Emissions Inventory (EI) and Source Apportionment (SA) Studies: Increase funding and resources to ensure that all cities complete EI and SA studies. This will help identify local and transboundary pollution sources accurately. Use sophisticated air quality modeling tools to understand pollution dispersion patterns and the impact of various mitigation measures. This will also help in addressing the impact of transboundary pollution.
Streamlining Implementation Processes: Develop and enforce standard operating procedures for the implementation of clean air action plans. This includes standardizing the technical specifications for procurement and reducing bureaucratic delays. Define clear timelines for each stage of the implementation process to ensure timely execution of pollution control measures.
Improving Policy and Regulatory Framework: Foster cooperation between states and regions to manage transboundary pollution effectively. This could include agreements on pollution reduction targets and joint action plans. Strengthen the enforcement of existing pollution control laws and update them as necessary to address new challenges and scientific findings.
Increasing Public Engagement and Awareness: Conduct extensive public awareness campaigns to educate citizens about the sources and health impacts of air pollution and the importance of pollution reduction measures. Engage community groups in monitoring air quality and implementing local clean air initiatives. This can increase public support and compliance with regulatory measures.
Leveraging Technology and Innovation: Promote cleaner technologies in industries, transportation, and energy sectors. This includes encouraging the adoption of electric vehicles, cleaner fuels, and industrial processes. Implement intelligent technologies like IoT-based sensors for real-time air quality monitoring and data collection. This can provide accurate and timely data to policymakers and the public.
Securing Financial Resources and Incentives: Ensure adequate funding for implementing clean air plans and provide financial incentives for industries and municipalities to adopt pollution control technologies. Link the disbursement of NCAP funds to achieving predefined air quality improvement targets to encourage better performance and accountability.
Building Capacity and Expertise: Conduct training programs for local government officials and technical staff on air quality management, including EI, SA, and air quality modeling. Partner with universities and research institutions to access technical expertise and innovative solutions for air pollution control.
THE CONCLUSION:
For NCAP to be successful, a comprehensive approach that includes rigorous scientific studies, strategic funding, and swift implementation of mitigation measures is necessary. It stresses the need for cities to utilize EI and SA data effectively to understand pollution sources and tailor their mitigation strategies accordingly.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTION:
Q. What are the key features of the National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) initiated by the Government of India? 2020
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q. Examine the challenges and strategies for effectively implementing the National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) in India. Discuss the role of scientific tools such as Emissions Inventory (EI), Air Quality (AQ) modeling, and Source Apportionment (SA) studies in aiding the NCAP’s objectives.
QUESTIONING THE POLLS ‘RAIN WASHES OUT PLAY’ MOMENTS
THE CONTEXT: The legal and procedural aspects of getting elected unopposed in Indian electoral laws, specifically under the Representation of the People Act of 1951, are a cause of concern. It explores the implications of such elections where candidates face no opposition, questioning the democratic integrity and voter engagement in these scenarios. The effectiveness of the NOTA option, as well as comparisons with public procurement rules, highlight the need for fairness and transparency in elections.
ISSUES:
Legality and Thrill of Unopposed Elections: Under current electoral laws, unopposed elections, in which a candidate emerges victorious without competition, are legally permissible. Such scenarios occur when the number of candidates is equal to or less than the seats available, leading to automatic victory as stipulated by electoral rules like Rule 11 of the Conduct of Election Rules 1961.
Democratic Rights and the NOTA Option: The process of unopposed elections raises questions about exercising democratic rights, particularly the absence of the “None of the Above” (NOTA) option in such cases. NOTA was introduced to allow voters to express disapproval of the candidates, but it does not influence the outcome directly. Its absence in unopposed elections means voters cannot express dissent in scenarios where there are no or limited candidate choices.
Impact on the Electoral Process: Unopposed elections can significantly impact the electoral process, potentially sidelining the electorate’s role in a democracy. This situation can lead to a paradox where the democratic process is technically upheld, but the spirit of democracy, which includes active participation and choice, is compromised.
Financial and Electoral Rules Comparison: The rules parallel electoral and financial laws, such as those in the General Financial Rules (GFRs) used for public procurement. Both rules aim for transparency and fairness; however, in electoral contexts, the lack of competition due to unopposed elections does not necessarily violate these principles, as the process still follows the laid-down procedures.
Potential for System Manipulation: The possibility of manipulating the electoral system with controlled or unopposed elections is a significant concern. This could theoretically allow a small number of candidates to undermine the democratic rights of a large electorate, highlighting a potential flaw in the system where the process is adhered to, but the democratic intent is not fulfilled.
Call for Debate: The issues identified call for a broader debate on electoral reforms to ensure that elections are not only free and fair in form but also substance, providing all voters with genuine opportunities to participate in the democratic process without being constrained by systemic limitations or manipulations.
THE WAY FORWARD:
Mandatory Participation: One solution to ensure higher voter engagement and prevent uncontested elections could be the introduction of compulsory voting. This practice, used in countries like Australia and Belgium, compels voters to participate in elections, reducing the likelihood of uncontested seats and enhancing democratic engagement.
NOTA Enhancement: Strengthening the “None of the Above” (NOTA) option could empower voters by allowing NOTA victories to trigger fresh elections with new candidates. This would ensure that political parties field candidates who better represent the electorate’s preferences.
Improving Candidate Diversity and Integrity: Revising the eligibility criteria for candidates to include mandatory public service or community engagement could ensure that candidates have a service history and commitment to public welfare, potentially increasing voter trust and participation.
Financial Transparency: Implementing stringent financial disclosure requirements for candidates could reduce corruption and increase transparency. Like the U.S. Federal Election Commission’s regulations, these measures would help build voter trust in the electoral process.
Proportional Representation: Adopting a proportional representation system could replace the first-past-the-post system, ensuring that all significant political perspectives are represented in the legislature, as seen in countries like New Zealand and Germany. This could prevent dominance by a single party and encourage more comprehensive representation.
Minimum Vote Threshold: Introducing a minimum vote threshold for election victory could ensure that elected representatives have substantial support. This would avoid situations where a small number of votes can lead to an election due to low voter turnout or multiple candidates splitting the vote.
Independent Election Commission: Strengthening the independence of the election commission by ensuring that its members are appointed through a bipartisan or judicial process, like Canada’s independent boundary commissions, could enhance the credibility and fairness of elections.
International Election Observers: Inviting international observers to monitor elections could help ensure electoral processes meet global democratic standards. This practice, common in many democracies, adds a layer of oversight and can help build international trust in the electoral process.
THE CONCLUSION:
Emphasizing the paradoxes and potential manipulations within the current electoral system when elections are uncontested or boycotted. It calls for a broader debate on electoral reforms, including the possibility of amending the first-past-the-post system and reevaluating the role of NOTA. The aim is to ensure that democratic processes are not only technically free and fair but also substantively representative and engaging for the electorate.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTION:
Q. Discuss the procedures to decide the disputes arising from the election of a Member of the Parliament or State Legislature under The Representation of the People Act, 1951. What are the grounds on which the election of any returned candidate may be declared void? What remedy is available to the aggrieved party against the decision? Refer to the case laws. 2022
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q. Examine the implications of candidates getting elected unopposed in the context of democratic principles and electoral laws. Discuss the potential impact on the exercise of democratic rights, especially when the NOTA option is not available. Suggest reforms that could address these issues to uphold the spirit of democracy.
SURAT SYMPTOMS: ON THE BJP AND THE ELIMINATION OF POLITICAL CONTEST
THE CONTEXT: The undermining of democratic competition in Surat, where the BJP candidate was elected unopposed to the Lok Sabha after the Congress candidate’s nomination papers were invalidated due to alleged forged signatures. The BJP’s objective of creating a “Congress-less India” suggests that such an intent is authoritarian and that the events in Surat represent unfair electoral practices.
ISSUES:
Elimination of Contest: There is a significant concern about the lack of electoral competition, particularly pointing out the unopposed election of the BJP candidate as a symptom of a broader malaise affecting Indian democracy. This situation arose due to the withdrawal of all other candidates and the rejection of the Congress candidate’s nomination over alleged discrepancies.
Authoritarian Intentions: The BJP’s declared objective of creating a “Congress-less India” reflects an authoritarian intent, even if pursued through what might appear as legitimate electoral processes.
Misuse of State Power and Electoral Malpractice: It is alleged that the unopposed election resulted from foul tactics, including the misuse of state power and electoral malpractice. This includes the claim that signatures on the nomination papers of the Congress candidate, Nilesh Kumbhani, and his dummy candidate were forged.
Impact on Democracy: The lack of opposition and contestation of ideas is portrayed as detrimental to the health of India’s democracy. It is implied that such practices erode the democratic fabric by eliminating healthy political competition and debate.
Need for Democratic Reforms: The BJP needs to foster a political culture where disagreements are resolved through fair and open contests, suggesting that this is essential for the sustainability of democratic governance in India.
THE WAY FORWARD:
Enhanced Scrutiny and Transparency in Nomination Processes: To prevent forgery, nomination papers, and proposer signatures should be subject to stricter verification processes. This could involve cross-verification by independent bodies or technology to ensure authenticity.
Legal and Regulatory Reforms: Strengthening the legal framework to impose severe penalties for electoral fraud and manipulation could deter such practices. Additionally, reforms could be introduced to make the electoral process more transparent and accountable.
Role of the Election Commission: The Election Commission of India (ECI) needs to play a more proactive role in overseeing elections, ensuring that all candidates have a fair chance to contest. This includes rigorous monitoring of the election process and swift action against irregularities.
Voter Education and Awareness: Educating voters about their rights and the importance of a competitive electoral process is crucial. Awareness campaigns can empower voters to demand greater accountability and transparency from candidates and political parties.
Encouraging Political Pluralism: Policies to promote the participation of multiple political parties and independent candidates could help prevent the dominance of a single party. This might include financial support for smaller parties and fair access to media and public forums.
Judicial Oversight and Intervention: The judiciary should have a clear mandate to intervene in electoral malpractice cases. This would ensure an additional layer of oversight and maintain the integrity of electoral outcomes.
THE CONCLUSION:
The case of Surat is a stark reminder of the challenges facing Indian democracy. Addressing these challenges requires a multifaceted approach involving legal reforms, active regulatory oversight, and enhanced public engagement in the electoral process. Only through concerted efforts can the spirit of actual democratic competition be preserved, ensuring that elections are a genuine reflection of the people’s will.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTION:
Q. Discuss the procedures for deciding disputes arising from the election of a Member of the Parliament or State Legislature under The Representation of the People Act, 1951. What are the grounds on which the election of any returned candidate may be declared void? What remedy is available to the aggrieved party against the decision? Refer to the case laws. 2022
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q. Examine the implications of a candidate’s unopposed election on the democratic process in India. Considering the recent events in Surat, discuss the measures that need to be taken to ensure the integrity of electoral contests and the role of the Election Commission in upholding democratic principles.
THE CONTEXT: The Environment Performance Index (EPI) 2022 placed India at the bottom among 180 countries, highlighting significant environmental challenges despite various government initiatives to improve living standards and environmental health. The government’s response criticized the EPI’s methodology, arguing it fails to reflect the Indian context accurately. This backdrop sets the stage for a deeper examination of India’s environmental policies and their effectiveness.
ISSUES:
Faulty Methodology Claim: The Indian government has contested the EPI ranking, arguing that the methodology is flawed and does not objectively quantify the Indian scenario.
Government Missions and EPI: The government’s development campaigns, such as the Swachh Bharat Mission (SBM), Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation (AMRUT), Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY), and National Clean Air Programme (NCAP), are intended to improve living standards, which should align with the EPI’s focus areas. However, an increase in vulnerability due to air and water pollution has been observed.
Swachh Bharat Mission (SBM) Issues: Despite the SBM’s political success and aim to make sanitation a collective responsibility, it has been criticized for perpetuating caste-based sanitation practices. The Comptroller and Auditor General report highlighted issues with the quality of toilet construction, and studies have shown that access to sanitation remains a problem in slums and rural areas.
Waste Management Failures: The government’s approach to waste management through capital-intensive technologies has not been successful. Waste-to-energy plants and biological methanation have few success stories, and the outsourcing of waste management to private contractors has continued caste discrimination.
Privatization and Caste Discrimination: The privatization of sanitation services has led to the employment of marginalized communities, particularly Dalits, in waste management roles, perpetuating caste discrimination.
Insufficient Sanitation Inspectors: In Himachal Pradesh, for example, there is a shortage of sanitation inspectors, with some municipalities having none. This shortage hampers the effective management of sanitation services.
Sustainability of Development Models: The EPI’s mapping feature highlights the unsustainability of current development models in India, suggesting a need for change.
Climate Change and Human Rights: The Supreme Court of India has observed links between climate change and fundamental human rights. Policies must be linked to human rights considerations to address the systemic and anthropogenic causes of environmental issues.
THE WAY FORWARD:
Inclusive Policy Design: Development models must be inclusive, considering the needs of all communities, mainly those historically marginalized, to prevent the perpetuation of discrimination and inequality.
Quality Control and Monitoring: Strengthen government programs’ monitoring and evaluation mechanisms to ensure quality control in constructing infrastructure like toilets and waste treatment facilities.
Infrastructure for Waste Treatment: Link toilet construction with waste treatment solutions, especially in rural and peri-urban areas, to prevent environmental contamination.
Empowerment and Dignity of Workers: Provide training and better working conditions for sanitation workers, recognizing their contribution to public health and the environment.
Effective Use of Funds: Ensure that funds allocated for environmental and sanitation projects are used effectively and that city governments are held accountable for their expenditures.
Strengthen Legal Frameworks: Enforce existing laws and regulations that protect environmental and human rights and develop new ones where necessary to address emerging challenges.
Global Collaboration: Engage in international cooperation to learn from best practices and to seek technical and financial assistance for implementing sustainable development models.
THE CONCLUSION:
EPI’s comprehensive approach reveals the unsustainable nature of India’s development models. It emphasizes the need for a paradigm shift in policymaking to integrate human rights with environmental and public health strategies, echoing recent judicial observations linking climate change to fundamental human rights. This shift is crucial for addressing the systemic issues that underpin India’s environmental challenges.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTION:
Q.1 What impediments exist in disposing of the vast quantities of discarded solid wastes continuously generated? How do we safely remove the toxic wastes accumulating in our habitable environment? 2018
Q.2 What are the key features of the National Clean Air Program (NCAP) initiated by the Government of India? 2020
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q.1 Critically examine the impact of India’s development programs on its environmental performance in light of the recent ranking in the Environment Performance Index (EPI). Discuss the role of human rights in framing sustainable development policies.
EXPLORING SATURN’s MOONS: ENCELADUS, MIMAS, AND TITAN
TAG: GS 3: SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
THE CONTEXT: Enceladus, Saturn’s captivating moon, has recently garnered attention due to its potential to harbor life.
EXPLANATION:
Enceladus:
Despite being merely 313 miles (504 kilometers) in diameter, it boasts a significant feature: a liquid water ocean beneath its icy crust, stretching across the entirety of the moon’s surface.
The revelation of Enceladus’s hidden ocean stems from the groundbreaking Cassini-Huygens mission, a collaborative endeavor involving NASA, the European Space Agency, and the Italian Space Agency.
Conducted from 2004 to 2017, this mission meticulously probed Saturn, its majestic rings, and its diverse moons.
Among its myriad discoveries were plumes of water emanating from a sub-surface salty ocean, interacting with rocky structures at the ocean’s base.
Enceladus’s ocean mirrors Earth’s own aquatic expanses in some remarkable ways.
Researchers, utilizing instruments like the dust analyzer, have discerned crucial components within the moon’s icy grains.
Most notably, sodium chloride, or table salt, dominates the ocean’s saline composition.
Moreover, a plethora of carbon-based compounds, vital for biochemical processes, have been identified.
Additionally, the moon’s tidal heating mechanism generates internal energy, further enhancing its potential as a habitat for life forms.
Brightly reflective Enceladus appears above the center of the image
Recent Discoveries
In a significant development in 2023, scientists, including Fabian Klenner from the University of Washington, unearthed phosphate—a compound conducive to life—in ice grains originating from Enceladus’s ocean.
This discovery bolsters the moon’s candidacy as a viable environment for primitive life forms.
Moreover, experts speculate that Enceladus’s environment may resemble the conditions that nurtured life on Earth, fueling excitement for further exploration.
Future Missions
Enceladus’s allure has not escaped the attention of space agencies.
In 2022, NASA earmarked a mission to Enceladus with the second-highest priority, underscoring the moon’s scientific significance.
Likewise, the European Space Agency recently designated Enceladus as the primary target for its forthcoming mission, indicative of the global scientific community’s interest in unlocking the mysteries of this enigmatic moon.
Mimas: Unveiling Hidden Depths
Joining the ranks of celestial bodies harboring potential sub-surface oceans is Mimas, another of Saturn’s moons.
Beneath its icy exterior lies a vast concealed ocean, as unveiled by scientists in February of the current year.
This ocean possesses many of the fundamental ingredients conducive to hosting rudimentary extraterrestrial life forms.
Mimas’s revelation adds to a burgeoning family of icy moons within the Solar System suspected of concealing inner oceans.
This expanding roster includes other notable moons such as Europa and Ganymede of Jupiter, as well as Enceladus itself.
The existence of these subsurface oceans raises intriguing questions about the potential prevalence of habitable environments beyond Earth.
Titan: A World of Extremes
Beyond Enceladus and Mimas, Saturn boasts Titan, a moon renowned for its distinctive characteristics.
Titan stands out as the only moon in the Solar System with a substantial atmosphere, primarily composed of nitrogen with traces of methane.
Its surface features include vast methane lakes and rivers, evoking comparisons to Earth’s hydrological cycle.
Despite its frigid temperatures and hydrocarbon-rich environment, Titan intrigues scientists as a potential abode for life, albeit of a vastly different nature than terrestrial organisms.
The presence of liquid methane and ethane raises tantalizing possibilities for exotic forms of biochemistry, challenging our understanding of the conditions necessary to sustain life.
THE CONTEXT: After eight years since its inception, the Union Ministry of New and Renewable Energy is poised to expedite the finalization of a national policy on geothermal energy.
EXPLANATION:
The draft policy, initially proposed in 2016, aims to provide non-fiscal support for the development of the geothermal energy sector in India.
The draft policy was introduced in 2016 but has yet to be finalized.
The delay in finalizing the policy has prompted the government to reevaluate its approach.
Initially, the plan was to establish demonstration projects before finalizing the policy based on their success.
However, progress has been hindered by delays in ongoing projects, such as the 1 MW pilot project in Ladakh, undertaken by ONGC Ltd.
In light of the delays, the government has revised its strategy and aims to finalize the policy concurrently with the establishment of demonstration projects.
These projects are targeted to have a cumulative capacity of approximately 25 MW.
Sites like Barren Island in Andaman & Nicobar are being considered for these projects to bolster clean energy production across the islands.
Additionally, there are plans to explore the use of geothermal energy for green hydrogen production and domestic consumption, with potential export opportunities to Singapore.
Features of the Proposed Policy
The forthcoming policy is expected to provide primarily non-fiscal support to stakeholders venturing into the geothermal energy sector.
This support may include streamlined environmental clearances and simplified land acquisition processes.
The policy will likely align with the 2016 draft, which proposed measures such as awarding land for project development, maintenance of production wells, and soft loans akin to those provided for other renewable energy projects.
Geothermal Energy Potential and Exploration Efforts
Geothermal energy harnesses heat from the earth’s subsurface for various applications, including electricity generation and heating/cooling systems.
India is estimated to have the potential to produce 10 GW of geothermal energy, with exploration efforts previously conducted by the Geological Survey of India during the 1970s-1980s.
Unlike countries with hot lava resources, India primarily relies on hot rocks for geothermal energy, which produce less heat.
Contribution to Clean Energy Goals
The exploitation of geothermal resources aligns with India’s ambitious renewable energy targets, aiming for 500 GW of non-fossil capacity by 2030 and achieving net-zero carbon emissions by 2070.
Integrating geothermal energy into the energy mix would diversify India’s cleaner energy sources, contributing to its sustainability goals.
Geothermal energy:
Geothermal energy is thermal energy extracted from the Earth’s crust.
It combines energy from the formation of the planet and from radioactive decay. Geothermal energy has been exploited as a source of heat and/or electric power for millennia.
Geothermal heating, using water from hot springs, for example, has been used for bathing since Paleolithic times and for space heating since Roman times. Geothermal power, (generation of electricity from geothermal energy), has been used since the 20th century.
Unlike wind and solar energy, geothermal plants produce power at a constant rate, without regard to weather conditions.
Geothermal resources are theoretically more than adequate to supply humanity’s energy needs. Most extraction occurs in areas near tectonic plate boundaries.
India has huge potential to become a leading contributor in generating eco-friendly and cost effective geothermal power. Around 6.5 per cent of electricity generation in the world would be done with the help of geothermal energy and India would have to play a bigger role in the coming years in this direction. But, the power generation through geothermal resources is still in nascent stages in India.
Geological Survey of India has identified about 340 geothermal hot springs in the country. Most of them are in the low surface temperature range from 37oC -90oC which is suitable for direct heat applications. These springs are grouped into seven geothermal provinces i.e. Himalayan (Puga, Chhumathang), Sahara Valley, Cambay Basin, Son-Narmada-Tapi (SONATA) lineament belt, West Coast, Godavari basin and Mahanadi basin.
Some of the prominent geothermal resources include Puga Valley and Chhumathang in Jammu and Kashmir, Manikaran in Himachal Pradesh, Jalgaon in Maharashtra and Tapovan in Uttarakhand.
A new location of geothermal power energy has also been found in Tattapani in Chhattisgarh. In addition, Gujarat is set to tap geothermal electricity through resources which are available in Cambay between Narmada and Tapi river. Puga, which is located at a distance of about 180 km from Leh in the Ladakh region of Jammu and Kashmir across the great Himalayan range, is considered to be a good potential of geothermal energy.
In Puga valley, hot spring temperatures vary from 30oC to 84oC (boiling point at Puga) and discharge up to 300 liters /minute. A total of 34 boreholes ranging in depths from 28.5 m to 384.7 m have been drilled in Puga valley
THE CONTEXT: Recently, the Environment Ministry issued further guidelines on its Green Credit Programme (GCP), two months after it had prescribed rules governing the first initiative, afforestation.
The Green Credits Programme (GCP) is an initiative launched by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) in India.
It is an innovative market-based mechanism designed to incentivize voluntary environmental actions by generating and trading green credits across diverse sectors, by various stakeholders like individuals, communities, companies etc.
Green credits are tradable units that represent a specified environmental activity and its positive impact on the environment.
The GCP’s governance framework is supported by an inter-ministerial Steering Committee.
The Indian Council of Forestry Research and Education (ICFRE) serves as the GCP Administrator, responsible for program implementation, management, monitoring, and operation.
In its initial phase, the GCP focuses on two key activities:
Water conservation and
Afforestation
Draft methodologies for awarding Green Credits have been developed and will be notified for stakeholder consultation.
These methodologies set benchmarks for each activity/process, to ensure environmental impact and fungibility across sectors.
The Green Credit Registry and trading platform, being developed by ICFRE along with experts, would facilitate the registration and thereafter, the buying and selling of Green Credits.
The Administrator will grant a Green Credit certificate which will be tradable on the green credit platform.
Afforestation Initiative
Under the GCP, companies, organizations, and individuals can finance afforestation projects in specific degraded forest areas.
The State forest departments carry out the tree planting, with the ICFRE evaluating the projects.
After two years, each planted tree may be worth one green credit. Thirteen State Forest departments have offered nearly 10,983 hectares of degraded forest land for afforestation projects.
Participation and Investment
Several public sector companies, including Indian Oil, Power Grid Corporation of India, National Thermal Power Corporation, Oil India, Coal India, and National Hydropower Corporation, have registered to invest in the GCP.
However, the program has raised concerns and criticisms.
Controversies Surrounding GCP
Critics have raised several concerns about the GCP.
Firstly, there are apprehensions that it commodifies environmental conservation, potentially undermining existing forest conservation laws.
Some fear that it might serve as a loophole for industries involved in forest diversion for non-forestry purposes.
Secondly, there are doubts about the effectiveness of afforestation efforts in promoting ecosystem restoration, as planting inappropriate tree species could lead to invasive species proliferation or disrupt sustainable ecosystems.
Additionally, the integration of carbon trading into the program raises questions about the clarity of mathematical models equating carbon storage with afforestation efforts.
Government Response and Guidelines
In response to criticisms, the Ministry has issued guidelines for States to calculate the costs of restoring degraded forest landscapes.
Notably, the requirement of a minimum of 1,100 trees per hectare for reforestation has been revised to accommodate variations in forest conditions.
States are now empowered to specify suitable vegetation, including shrubs, herbs, and grasses, for ecosystem restoration.
Preference is given to indigenous species, although quantifying the contribution of shrubs and grasses to green credits is still being refined.
Furthermore, the Ministry clarified that companies cannot fully offset their compensatory afforestation obligations using green credits but can only claim a portion.
ENHANCING DRUG DISCOVERY: TOOLS AND COLLABORATIONS
TAG: GS 3: SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
THE CONTEXT: The quest for new drugs faces significant challenges, particularly in combating antimicrobial resistance. Collaborative efforts, sophisticated tools, and innovative approaches are essential to bridge the gap between identifying drug targets and developing effective treatments.
One group investigated the expansion of bacterial cell walls in Escherichia coli, identifying potential drug targets among peptidoglycan hydrolase enzymes.
Another group explored protein degradation mechanisms in the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum, uncovering enzymes crucial for its development.
Complexity of Drug Discovery:
Despite the identification of numerous potential drug targets worldwide, the translation into effective drugs remains challenging due to the complexity of the process.
Tools and Techniques in Drug Discovery
Assay Development:
Reddy developed robust assays to visualize the interaction of drug-like molecules with target enzymes, facilitating the early stages of drug discovery.
Structural Biology Challenges:
Determining enzyme structures poses challenges, especially for large molecules like those studied by the second group.
Structural information is crucial for designing targeted inhibitors.
Molecular Docking Simulations:
To overcome structural limitations, scientists utilize molecular docking simulations.
By fitting small drug-like compounds into target molecule structures, researchers predict binding affinity and potential efficacy.
Chemical Libraries:
Access to libraries of approved drugs and chemical compounds expedites drug discovery.
These libraries provide a vast array of molecules for screening against identified drug targets.
Artificial Intelligence (AI):
AI-driven programs aid in predicting potential drug structures and optimizing existing molecules.
Collaboration with AI-based companies enhances computational drug discovery efforts.
Challenges and Solutions
High-Throughput Screening:
Drug companies conduct high-throughput screening to test thousands or millions of molecules for efficacy.
Collaboration between academia and industry accelerates this process.
Safety and Efficacy Testing:
Molecules identified as potential inhibitors undergo rigorous testing for safety and efficacy.
Startups and contract research labs play a crucial role in preclinical testing stages.
Regulatory Approval:
Successful candidates from preclinical testing proceed to clinical trials, where regulatory oversight ensures ethical conduct and unbiased data collection.
THE CONTEXT: Recently, a study has warned that the warming planet may alter the characteristics of tundra environments and could transform them from carbon sinks to carbon sources.
It examines how rising temperatures affect ecosystem respiration, which comprises all respiration activities by living organisms in a specific ecosystem.
Experimental Approach
Over 70 scientists conducted open-top-chamber warming experiments at 28 arctic and alpine tundra sites over a span of 25 years.
These chambers simulated global warming by passively increasing air temperatures, allowing researchers to observe the effects on the ecosystem.
Key Findings of the study:
Impact of Temperature Rise: A mean increase of 1.4 degrees Celsius in air temperature, accompanied by a 0.4°C rise in soil temperature and a 1.6% decrease in soil moisture, led to a significant 30% increase in respiration during the growing season.
Contributors to Increased Respiration: The heightened activity was attributed to both plant and microbial respiration, resulting in the release of carbon into the atmosphere.
Sensitivity to Warming: Tundra regions with higher nitrogen limitations and sites that stimulated plant and microbial turnover exhibited greater sensitivity to warming, showcasing varied respiration responses.
Nonlinear Trend: The study uncovered a nonlinear trend in ecosystem respiration increase over time, particularly between 5 and 15 years of warming. This pattern suggests differing rates of reaction among microbial and plant processes to warming.
The researchers postulated that the nonlinear pattern could stem from immediate effects of warming on microbial and plant respiration, such as accelerated decomposition, contrasted with slower impacts like changes in biogeochemical and hydrological soil conditions.
Implications and Future Directions
Global Impact: The rate of warming in the tundra biome surpasses the global average, indicating the urgent need to incorporate tundra carbon cycles into climate models for accurate predictions of future carbon emissions.
Importance of Soil Factors: Detailed understanding of soil nitrogen, carbon, pH, and their interplay with respiration in response to warming is crucial for refining climate models and projecting future warming scenarios accurately.
Policy and Climate Modeling: The results from the experiment can inform the development of more precise global and regional climate models, aiding policymakers in formulating effective strategies to mitigate climate change.
Tundra Ecosystem:
The tundra ecosystem is a biome characterized by its extremely cold climate, low temperatures, and short growing seasons.
It is primarily found in the polar regions, including the Arctic tundra in the Northern Hemisphere and the alpine tundra at high altitudes in mountain ranges.
Tundra ecosystems are almost treeless areas where environmental conditions are very severe.
The tundra of Antarctica offers a distinct and comparatively unspoiled setting for scientific study, providing information on biodiversity, glaciology, and climate change.
Because Antarctica is sensitive to temperature fluctuations, it is an essential gauge for monitoring changes in the world’s climate.
Studies of Antarctica’s vast ice sheets are essential to understanding ice dynamics, sea level rise, and possible effects on the planet’s climate.
With treaties and agreements in place to protect its distinctive environment, the region is crucial to worldwide conservation efforts.
Demilitarised by the Antarctic Treaty, Antarctica is a region of international cooperation that promotes harmonious cooperation between states.
Antarctica has distinctive prospects for educational establishments, stimulating curiosity in the scientific realm.
ENSURING THE FUTURE: ON HEALTH INSURANCE AND A WIDE DEMOGRAPHIC OF CITIZENS
THE CONTEXT: The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) has mandated that insurance companies offer health insurance to all age groups, including senior citizens above 65, previously excluded from purchasing new policies. This directive is in response to the demographic shift in India, where the senior population is expected to grow significantly, mirroring trends in developed countries where access to healthcare and insurance is a concern for the aging population.
ISSUES:
Demographic Shifts: India is experiencing significant demographic changes, with an aging population expected to grow substantially in the coming decades. The proportion of seniors—those above 60—is projected to rise from about 10% of the population in 2022 to 30% by 2050. This shift necessitates a robust healthcare infrastructure and accessible health insurance to manage the increasing healthcare needs of an aging population.
Healthcare Accessibility and Affordability: Removing the age cap for health insurance is a step towards improving healthcare accessibility. However, the challenge remains in making these health insurance policies affordable, especially for the senior demographic, which often faces higher healthcare costs. The economic burden of healthcare can be significant, particularly as health insurance premiums tend to increase with age.
Insurance Policy Design: IRDAI has mandated insurance companies to design products that cater specifically to various demographic groups, including senior citizens, students, and children. This includes the development of policies that cover pre-existing conditions and do not require medical check-ups for policy renewal. Such tailored policies are essential for addressing the specific needs of these groups.
Challenges in Implementation: Despite the regulatory changes, implementing these policies can be challenging. Insurers might be hesitant to cover older age groups due to the higher risk and cost associated with their healthcare. Moreover, the terms and conditions of such policies may not always be favorable to customers, particularly the elderly.
Economic Implications: The financial implications of an aging population are profound, affecting not just healthcare but also the broader economy. The need for affordable health insurance becomes even more critical as the traditional caregiving structures in India evolve, with more individuals moving out of agriculture and familial support systems changing.
Policy and Public Health Infrastructure: To truly benefit from these regulatory changes, the public health infrastructure must be upgraded concurrently. Affordable and accessible healthcare services are crucial to complement health insurance schemes so that the financial protection provided by insurance can be effectively utilized.
THE WAY FORWARD:
Inclusive Policy Design: Insurers should design health insurance products that are affordable and cater to the needs of senior citizens, including those with pre-existing conditions. IRDAI has already reduced the waiting period for pre-existing diseases from 48 to 36 months, which should be further minimized to enhance coverage.
Upgradation of Healthcare Infrastructure: The government and private sector must invest in healthcare infrastructure to meet the increased demand from a growing senior population. A focus on training more healthcare professionals, including senior specialists, to provide quality care to the elderly should also be made.
Financial Support Mechanisms: The government could offer subsidies or tax benefits to make health insurance more affordable for seniors and encourage uptake. Collaborations between the government and private insurers can lead to innovative insurance products that are both comprehensive and cost-effective.
Awareness and Education: Widespread campaigns should educate the public about the importance of health insurance and the options available, especially for the elderly. Purchasing and claiming health insurance should be simplified to make it more accessible to seniors who may not be as tech-savvy.
Regulatory Oversight: IRDAI should monitor the implementation of these policies to ensure that they are effective and that insurers comply with the guidelines to serve the senior demographic.
THE CONCLUSION:
While the IRDAI’s move to include senior citizens in health insurance coverage is a positive step, it must be paired with affordable healthcare services. It is highly suggestive that the broadening of health insurance eligibility should go hand in hand with an upgrade in healthcare infrastructure to truly benefit India’s aging population, especially as traditional caregiving structures evolve.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTIONS:
Q.1 To enhance the prospects of social development, sound and adequate healthcare policies are needed, particularly in geriatric and maternal healthcare. Discuss. 2020
Q.2 The public health system has limitations in providing universal health coverage. Do you think that the private sector could help in bridging the gap? What other viable alternatives would you suggest? 2015
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q.1 Critically analyze the implications of India’s demographic shift towards an aging population for the health insurance sector and the measures taken by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) to address these challenges. Discuss the potential impact of these measures on the accessibility and affordability of health care for senior citizens.
FOUR WAYS THE ISRAEL-HAMAS-IRAN CONFLICT HAS LED TO A MORE VOLATILE MIDDLE EAST
THE CONTEXT: Israel’s military campaign to eliminate Hamas has led to the destruction of Gaza and a humanitarian crisis. Iran and its allies have united in support of the Palestinian cause, escalating regional tensions. Recent Iranian attacks on Israel and Israeli strikes on Iranian interests have changed the dynamics of the conflict.
ISSUES:
Regional Unity and Shia-Sunni Relations: The conflict has led to a thawing of the traditionally icy Shia-Sunni relations. Shia groups like Hezbollah and the Houthis, along with Iran, have shown open support for the Sunni Palestinians. This marks a significant shift towards regional unity against perceived US-Israeli dominance, highlighting the formation of what is referred to as the Axis of Resistance.
Expansion of the Conflict: The war has broadened its scope and affected not just the immediate region but also involved the US more directly. The US has become a central figure in trying to contain the conflict’s expansion, with its bases across Syria, Iraq, and Jordan being targeted by hundreds of rocket and drone attacks since October 7. The US and Iran have managed to avoid direct military confrontation, but the situation remains volatile, with ongoing challenges in restraining all state and non-state actors involved.
Diplomatic Shifts in the Arab World: Sunni Arab states, aligned with Saudi Arabia, have opted for a diplomatic approach, advocating for ceasefires and supporting humanitarian efforts. They have also called for a two-state solution, aligning with US-led peace initiatives. Notably, Saudi Arabia has paused its normalization of ties with Israel, conditioning any diplomatic relations on the recognition of an independent Palestinian state with pre-1967 borders and East Jerusalem as its capital.
Maritime Disruptions by Houthis: The Houthis have effectively disrupted a critical maritime communication lane, impacting global trade. Environmental factors like drought conditions in the Panama Canal have compounded this disruption, forcing costly adjustments in global shipping routes and schedules.
Economic Impact and Military Engagements: The Israeli economy has faced significant strain, with estimates of the war costing over a quarter of a billion dollars daily as of October last year. The conflict has led to a 20% shrinkage in the Israeli economy in the previous quarter of 2023. Military engagements have continued with Israel asserting its determination to eliminate Hamas and secure the release of all hostages, despite international calls for restraint and alternative strategies to direct ground operations.
THE WAY FORWARD:
Revival of Dialogue and Negotiations: Immediate efforts should focus on reviving dialogue between Israel and Hamas, with the mediation of the US, Qatar, and Egypt. This should aim at negotiating a prolonged ceasefire, ensuring the flow of humanitarian aid to Gaza, and securing the release of remaining Israeli hostages.
International Mediation for Israel-Iran Conflict: An international initiative, possibly under the auspices of the UN or involving significant powers like the EU, should mediate a sustainable ceasefire between Israel and Iran. This initiative should facilitate direct talks to build trust and find common ground.
Engagement of Regional Powers: Regional powers, including Saudi Arabia and other Gulf states, should be actively involved in advocating for peace and supporting diplomatic efforts. Their role in pushing for a two-state solution and normalization processes aligned with the 1967 borders could be crucial.
Comprehensive Security Framework: Develop a regional security architecture that includes confidence-building measures, arms control agreements, and conflict resolution mechanisms. This framework should involve all stakeholders in the Middle East to ensure collective security and stability.
Restrained Military Response: While Israel’s security concerns are valid, it should aim for a restrained military response coordinated with international law and humanitarian considerations. The focus should be on defensive measures rather than offensive actions that escalate the conflict.
Disarmament Initiatives: Operationalize UN decisions regarding the disarmament of weapons of mass destruction in the Middle East. This includes revisiting and strengthening the Iran nuclear deal (JCPOA) with the involvement of the United States and Iran.
THE CONCLUSION:
There is a possibility of talks between Hamas and Israel, mediated by the US, Qatar, and Egypt. The broader Middle East has been destabilized, with shifting alliances and increased regional conflict. The economic and strategic costs of the war are significant, and the Israel-Iran conflict poses a long-term threat to regional peace and stability.
UPSC PAST YEAR QUESTION:
Q.1 A number of outside powers have entrenched themselves in Central Asia, which is a zone of interest to India. Discuss the implications, in this context, of India’s joining the Ashgabat Agreement in 2018. 2018
MAINS PRACTICE QUESTION:
Q.1 Analyze the implications of the recent Israel-Iran conflict on the geopolitical landscape of the Middle East. Discuss the role of international actors in managing the crisis and suggest measures that could lead to sustainable peace in the region.
You have already completed the quiz before. Hence you can not start it again.
Quiz is loading...
You must sign in or sign up to start the quiz.
You have to finish following quiz, to start this quiz:
Results
0 of 5 questions answered correctly
Your time:
Time has elapsed
You have reached 0 of 0 points, (0)
Categories
Not categorized0%
1
2
3
4
5
Answered
Review
Question 1 of 5
1. Question
1. Consider the following statements:
Statement-I: Jharkhand, Odisha, and Chhattisgarh account for almost 70% of the total known coal reserves in India.
Statement-II: The main areas of Gondwana rocks in the peninsular India are along the Damodar Valley, Mahanadi river valley and in a series of troughs along the Godavari.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?
Correct
Answer: A
Explanation: Both Statement-I and Statement-II are correct and Statement-II is the correct explanation for Statement-I
Gondwana System:
● The Gondwana System derives its name Gonds, the most primitive people of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh.
● They are deposits laid down in synclinal troughs on ancient plateau surface.
● As the sediments accumulated, the loaded troughs subsided.
● Fresh water and sediments accumulated in these trough and terrestrial plants and animals thrived.
● This has happened since the Permian period (250 million years ago).
Gondwana Coal:
● Gondwana rocks contain nearly 98 per cent of India’s coal reserves.
● Gondwana coal is much younger than the Carboniferous coal and hence its carbon content is low.
● They have rich deposits of iron ore, copper, uranium and antimony also.
● Sandstones, slates and conglomerates are used as building materials.
Distribution of Gondwana rocks:
Incorrect
Answer: A
Explanation: Both Statement-I and Statement-II are correct and Statement-II is the correct explanation for Statement-I
Gondwana System:
● The Gondwana System derives its name Gonds, the most primitive people of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh.
● They are deposits laid down in synclinal troughs on ancient plateau surface.
● As the sediments accumulated, the loaded troughs subsided.
● Fresh water and sediments accumulated in these trough and terrestrial plants and animals thrived.
● This has happened since the Permian period (250 million years ago).
Gondwana Coal:
● Gondwana rocks contain nearly 98 per cent of India’s coal reserves.
● Gondwana coal is much younger than the Carboniferous coal and hence its carbon content is low.
● They have rich deposits of iron ore, copper, uranium and antimony also.
● Sandstones, slates and conglomerates are used as building materials.
Distribution of Gondwana rocks:
Question 2 of 5
2. Question
2. Consider the following trees:
1. White Cedar
2. Magnolia
3. Hollock
4. Kail
5. Rosewood
How many of the above are semi-evergreen trees found in India?
Correct
Answer: B
Explanation: White Cedar, Hallock and Kail are examples of the semi evergreen trees found in India.
On the basis of certain common features such as predominant vegetation type and climatic regions, Indian forests can be divided into the following groups:
Types of Forests:
I. Tropical Evergreen and Semi Evergreen forests
II. Tropical Deciduous forests
III. Tropical Thorn forests
IV. Montane forests
V. Littoral and Swamp forests
Tropical Evergreen and Semi Evergreen Forests
Tropical Evergreen Forests:
● These forests are found in the western slope of the Western Ghats, hills of the northeastern region and the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
● They are found in warm and humid areas with an annual precipitation of over 200 cm and mean annual temperature above 22 degree C.
● In these forests, trees reach great heights up to 60 m or above. There is no definite time for trees to shed their leaves, flowering and fruition. As such these forests appear green all the year round. Species found in these forests include rosewood, mahogony, aini, ebony, etc.
Semi Evergreen Forests:
● The semi evergreen forests are found in the less rainy parts of these regions.
● Such forests have a mixture of evergreen and moist deciduous trees. The undergrowing climbers provide an evergreen character to these forests.
● Main species are white cedar, hollock and kail.
Note: Magnolia, Laurel, Cinchona and Wattle are the examples of the Southern Mountain Forests.
Incorrect
Answer: B
Explanation: White Cedar, Hallock and Kail are examples of the semi evergreen trees found in India.
On the basis of certain common features such as predominant vegetation type and climatic regions, Indian forests can be divided into the following groups:
Types of Forests:
I. Tropical Evergreen and Semi Evergreen forests
II. Tropical Deciduous forests
III. Tropical Thorn forests
IV. Montane forests
V. Littoral and Swamp forests
Tropical Evergreen and Semi Evergreen Forests
Tropical Evergreen Forests:
● These forests are found in the western slope of the Western Ghats, hills of the northeastern region and the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
● They are found in warm and humid areas with an annual precipitation of over 200 cm and mean annual temperature above 22 degree C.
● In these forests, trees reach great heights up to 60 m or above. There is no definite time for trees to shed their leaves, flowering and fruition. As such these forests appear green all the year round. Species found in these forests include rosewood, mahogony, aini, ebony, etc.
Semi Evergreen Forests:
● The semi evergreen forests are found in the less rainy parts of these regions.
● Such forests have a mixture of evergreen and moist deciduous trees. The undergrowing climbers provide an evergreen character to these forests.
● Main species are white cedar, hollock and kail.
Note: Magnolia, Laurel, Cinchona and Wattle are the examples of the Southern Mountain Forests.
Question 3 of 5
3. Question
3. Consider the following statements:
1. Bairabi-Sairang railway line project will connect Arunachal Pradesh with the rest of the country.
2. Kokrajhar-Gelephu railway line project will connect Assam with Mizoram.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Correct
Answer: D
Explanation: None of the statements is correct
Statement 1 is incorrect:
About Bairabi-Sairang railway line project:
● The Northeast Frontier Railway (NFR) zone of Indian Railways has been given responsibility for the execution of the project, which will connect Mizoram, one of the eight northeastern states of India, with other parts of the country.
● In addition to enhancing connectivity, the project will also boost tourism in the state, leading to the generation of employment for localities.
Connectivity to neighbouring countries:
● The railway project will play a pivotal role in the development of Mizoram, which is known for its scenic beauty, rich culture and biodiversity, and ease the transportation system for the residents of the states, who are mostly dependent on roads and airways.
● In addition to the development of the state, the project will also enhance its connectivity with neighbouring countries, Myanmar and Bangladesh, as part of the Trans-Asian Railway network and the Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project.
Statement 2 is incorrect:
Kokrajhar-Gelephu railway line project:
● It aims to connect Kokrajhar in Assam, India, to Gelephu in Bhutan, enhancing trade and connectivity between the two countries.
● It holds strategic importance, offering an alternative transportation route and boosting cross-border trade and economic cooperation.
● The project involves significant infrastructure development and requires environmental and social impact assessments.
Incorrect
Answer: D
Explanation: None of the statements is correct
Statement 1 is incorrect:
About Bairabi-Sairang railway line project:
● The Northeast Frontier Railway (NFR) zone of Indian Railways has been given responsibility for the execution of the project, which will connect Mizoram, one of the eight northeastern states of India, with other parts of the country.
● In addition to enhancing connectivity, the project will also boost tourism in the state, leading to the generation of employment for localities.
Connectivity to neighbouring countries:
● The railway project will play a pivotal role in the development of Mizoram, which is known for its scenic beauty, rich culture and biodiversity, and ease the transportation system for the residents of the states, who are mostly dependent on roads and airways.
● In addition to the development of the state, the project will also enhance its connectivity with neighbouring countries, Myanmar and Bangladesh, as part of the Trans-Asian Railway network and the Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project.
Statement 2 is incorrect:
Kokrajhar-Gelephu railway line project:
● It aims to connect Kokrajhar in Assam, India, to Gelephu in Bhutan, enhancing trade and connectivity between the two countries.
● It holds strategic importance, offering an alternative transportation route and boosting cross-border trade and economic cooperation.
● The project involves significant infrastructure development and requires environmental and social impact assessments.
Question 4 of 5
4. Question
4. Consider the following statements:
Statement-I: Western cyclonic disturbance causes rainfall in Punjab, Haryana, Delhi and western Uttar Pradesh.
Statement-II: The easterly jet stream plays an important role in bringing the winter rains in Northern India.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?
Correct
Answer: C
Explanation: Statement-I is correct but Statement-II is incorrect
Statement-II is incorrect:
Western Cyclonic Disturbance:
● The western cyclonic disturbances which enter the Indian subcontinent from the west and the northwest during the winter months, originate over the Mediterranean Sea and are brought into India by the westerly jet stream.
Statement-I is incorrect:
● In northwestern India, some weak temperate cyclones from the Mediterranean Sea cause rainfall in Punjab, Haryana, Delhi and western Uttar Pradesh.
● Although the amount is meagre, it is highly beneficial for rabi crops.
● The precipitation is in the form of snowfall in the lower Himalayas.
● It is this snow that sustains the flow of water in the Himalayan rivers during the summer months.
● The precipitation goes on decreasing from west to east in the plains and from north to south in the mountains.
Incorrect
Answer: C
Explanation: Statement-I is correct but Statement-II is incorrect
Statement-II is incorrect:
Western Cyclonic Disturbance:
● The western cyclonic disturbances which enter the Indian subcontinent from the west and the northwest during the winter months, originate over the Mediterranean Sea and are brought into India by the westerly jet stream.
Statement-I is incorrect:
● In northwestern India, some weak temperate cyclones from the Mediterranean Sea cause rainfall in Punjab, Haryana, Delhi and western Uttar Pradesh.
● Although the amount is meagre, it is highly beneficial for rabi crops.
● The precipitation is in the form of snowfall in the lower Himalayas.
● It is this snow that sustains the flow of water in the Himalayan rivers during the summer months.
● The precipitation goes on decreasing from west to east in the plains and from north to south in the mountains.
Question 5 of 5
5. Question
5. Consider the following statements:
1. Heatwave is declared when the departure from normal temperature is by 4.5 to 6.4 degrees Celsius.
2. The Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) considers severe heat waves when the actual maximum temperature is more than 45 degrees Celsius.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Correct
Answer: A
Explanation: Statement 1 is correct
Statement 1 is correct
What is a heatwave?
● The IMD says heatwave is considered when the maximum temperature of a station touches at least 40 degrees Celsius or more for plains, 37 degrees Celsius or more for coastal regions and at least 30 degrees Celsius or more for hilly regions.
What are the criteria?
● Heatwave is declared when the departure from normal temperature is by 4.5 to 6.4 degrees Celsius.
Statement 2 is incorrect:
● A severe heatwave is when the departure from normal is more than 6.4 degrees Celsius.
● For plains, based on actual maximum temperature, IMD considers heat waves when actual maximum temperature is more than 45 degrees Celsius and severe heat waves when it is more than 47 degrees Celsius.
Incorrect
Answer: A
Explanation: Statement 1 is correct
Statement 1 is correct
What is a heatwave?
● The IMD says heatwave is considered when the maximum temperature of a station touches at least 40 degrees Celsius or more for plains, 37 degrees Celsius or more for coastal regions and at least 30 degrees Celsius or more for hilly regions.
What are the criteria?
● Heatwave is declared when the departure from normal temperature is by 4.5 to 6.4 degrees Celsius.
Statement 2 is incorrect:
● A severe heatwave is when the departure from normal is more than 6.4 degrees Celsius.
● For plains, based on actual maximum temperature, IMD considers heat waves when actual maximum temperature is more than 45 degrees Celsius and severe heat waves when it is more than 47 degrees Celsius.
IRDAI’S POLICY CHANGES: A NEW ERA IN HEALTH INSURANCE
TAG: GS 3: ECONOMY
THE CONTEXT: The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) has made a significant policy shift by abolishing the age cap on purchasing health insurance policies, effective April 1, 2024.
EXPLANATION:
Previously, individuals were restricted to acquiring new insurance policies only until the age of 65.
However, this change allows people of any age to purchase new health insurance policies.
IRDAI’s decision aims to foster a more inclusive healthcare ecosystem in India. By eliminating age restrictions, the regulatory body intends to provide equal access to health insurance across all age groups.
This move aligns with efforts to enhance healthcare accessibility and affordability for individuals, irrespective of their age.
Product Diversification Mandate
In addition to lifting the age cap, IRDAI has mandated insurance providers to diversify their product offerings to cater to various demographics.
Insurers are required to design health insurance products tailored to specific groups, including senior citizens, students, children, maternity, and others as specified by the Competent Authority.
This directive encourages insurers to develop specialized policies that address the unique healthcare needs of different segments of the population.
Focused Policies for Senior Citizens
Recognizing the distinct requirements of senior citizens, IRDAI has directed insurers to introduce dedicated policies for this demographic.
These specialized policies should be accompanied by established channels for handling senior citizens’ claims and grievances.
This ensures that elderly policyholders receive personalized support and assistance throughout their insurance journey.
Impact on Insurers and Policyholders
Industry experts view IRDAI’s decision as a positive development, as it expands healthcare coverage opportunities for individuals above the age of 65.
Insurers can now cover senior citizens based on their Board-approved Underwriting guidelines, subject to affordability for policyholders and viability for insurers.
Moreover, insurers are prohibited from refusing policies to individuals with severe medical conditions, such as cancer or heart failure, promoting inclusivity in insurance coverage.
Reduction in Waiting Period and Coverage of Pre-existing Conditions
IRDAI has reduced the health insurance waiting period from 48 months to 36 months, allowing coverage for pre-existing conditions after this timeframe.
Insurers are obligated to cover all pre-existing conditions after 36 months, regardless of whether policyholders disclosed them initially.
This regulation prevents insurers from rejecting claims based on pre-existing conditions after the specified waiting period, enhancing policyholders’ financial protection.
Transition to Benefit-based Policies
In a notable shift, IRDAI has prohibited insurers from introducing indemnity-based health policies and mandated the provision of benefit-based policies.
Benefit-based policies offer fixed costs upon the occurrence of a covered disease, streamlining the claims process and ensuring clarity for policyholders.
Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI):
The powers and functions of the Authority are laid down in the IRDAI Act, 1999 and Insurance Act, 1938.
Its head office is located in Hyderabad and Regional offices at New Delhi and Mumbai. The Regional Office, New Delhi focuses on spreading consumer awareness and handling of Insurance grievances besides providing required support for inspection of Insurance companies and other regulated entities located in the Northern Region.
This office is functionally responsible for licensing of Surveyors and Loss Assessors. Regional Office at Mumbai handles similar activities, as in Regional Office Delhi, pertaining to Western Region.
The key objectives of the IRDAI include promotion of competition so as to enhance customer satisfaction through increased consumer choice and fair premiums, while ensuring the financial security of the Insurance market.
The Insurance Act, 1938 is the principal Act governing the Insurance sector in India.
It provides the powers to IRDAI to frame regulations which lay down the regulatory framework for supervision of the entities operating in the sector.
Further, there are certain other Acts which govern specific lines of Insurance business and functions such as Marine Insurance Act, 1963 and Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991.
Composition of IRDAI:
As per Sec. 4 of IRDAI Act, 1999, the composition of the Authority is:
THE CONTEXT: Recently, the spotlight has returned on high sugar content in flavoured malt-based milk powders and baby food. Government authorities are warning against branding such items as “healthy” and have called out the allegedly misleading promotion and marketing tactics while loading products with added sugar.
EXPLANATION:
Sugar Content in Processed Foods
Processed foods, particularly flavored malt-based milk powders and baby food, have come under scrutiny due to their high sugar content.
Government authorities caution against labeling such items as “healthy” while their promotion and marketing tactics allegedly mislead consumers by concealing added sugars.
For example, a popular malt-based drink like Bournvita contains significant amounts of carbohydrates and sugars, with a notable portion being added sugar.
The malting process itself generates sugars, further contributing to the product’s high sugar content.
FSSAI’s regulations stipulate that products claiming to be “low on sugar” must contain less than 5g of total sugar per 100g.
However, many products fail to meet this criterion while marketing themselves as “health drinks,” potentially leading consumers, especially children, to exceed recommended sugar intake limits.
Controversy Over Baby Food
The controversy extends to baby food, where products like Cerelac contain significant sugar levels, raising concerns about early exposure to high-sugar diets in infants.
The addition of ingredients like maltodextrin for flavor and texture exacerbates the issue, as it has a higher glycemic index than table sugar.
Excess sugar consumption in infants can strain the pancreas, potentially leading to diabetes and obesity later in life.
Despite regulations, some companies continue to market such products as suitable for infants, violating established guidelines.
FSSAI’s Regulatory Measures
In September 2022, FSSAI proposed draft regulations targeting high-fat, sugar, salt (HFSS) foods.
These regulations aim to inform consumers about the nutritional content of products through front-of-the-pack labeling.
However, the effectiveness of such measures remains uncertain, as the regulations lack clarity on whether companies must disclose fat, sugar, and salt content on product packaging.
Additionally, the introduction of health rating stars as an alternative to warning labels has drawn criticism from experts, who argue that such ratings may mislead consumers.
Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI):
It is an autonomous body established under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India.
The FSSAI has been established under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, which is a consolidating statute related to food safety and regulation in India.
Vision: Build a new India by enabling citizens to have safe and nutritious food, prevent diseases, and lead a healthy and happy life.
Mission: Set globally benchmarked standards for food, encourage and ensure that food businesses adhere to these standards, adopt good manufacturing and hygiene practices, and ultimately enable citizens to access safe and right food.
INDIA’S APPROACH TO SINGLE-USE PLASTICS REGULATION
TAG: GS 3: ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT
THE CONTEXT: Ahead of the forthcoming U.N. negotiations in Toronto, Canada, involving 192 countries aimed at addressing global plastic pollution, India’s position on single-use plastics stands out.
EXPLANATION:
While many countries advocate for outright bans on problematic plastics, India favors a regulatory approach.
According to analysis by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), India has opted to regulate rather than eliminate the production, sale, import, and export of problematic and avoidable plastic goods.
These items encompass disposable plastic goods intended for single-use, such as plastic cups, spoons, earbuds, and packaging materials.
However, notable exclusions from the ban include plastic bottles (including those less than 200ml) and multi-layered packaging boxes like those used in milk cartons.
Despite the ban, enforcement varies across the country, with some outlets continuing to distribute prohibited items.
The rationale behind the selective ban derives from an expert committee’s assessment of the utility and environmental impact of different plastic goods.
Global Efforts and Differing Perspectives
The U.N. negotiations aim to implement both global and national measures to address plastic pollution, including removing problematic plastics from the market, reducing production through alternative practices or substitutes, and redesigning items for sustainable and safe product design.
However, countries’ positions vary based on factors such as their economic reliance on plastic production, recycling capabilities, and waste management infrastructure.
The European Union proposes stringent restrictions on the production and sale of certain plastic categories, aligning with a more prohibitive stance.
In contrast, the United States shares India’s perspective, advocating for each country to devise its own list of problematic and avoidable plastics.
Challenges in Achieving Consensus
Despite efforts to combat plastic pollution, the negotiation process faces significant challenges.
The CSE highlights that many oil, gas, and plastic-producing nations resist reducing primary/virgin plastic production.
Instead, they prioritize managing plastic waste over controlling production, reflecting a divergence in priorities.
Economic interests often influence member states’ positions, potentially weakening the provisions of the treaty.
Global Impact of Plastic Production
Plastic production has surged in recent decades, doubling over the past 20 years.
The United Nations attributes 99% of plastic production to polymers derived from non-renewable hydrocarbons, primarily crude oil and natural gas.
This production cycle contributes significantly to greenhouse gas emissions, with plastic production alone responsible for 90% of these emissions.
Steps taken by the Government:
Plastic Waste Management Amendment Rules, 2022: It prohibits the manufacture, import, stocking, distribution, sale and use of several single-use plastic items as of July 1, 2022. It has also mandated Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) that incorporates circularity by making manufacturers of products responsible for collecting and processing their products upon the end of the products’ lifetime.
Project REPLAN: Project REPLAN which stands for REducing PLastic in Nature has been launched by Khadi and Village Industries Commission (KVIC) aims to reduce consumption of plastic bags by providing a more sustainable alternative.
Ban on single-use plastics: India has banned the production, use, and sale of single-use plastics such as bags, cups, plates, cutlery, and straws in many states.
National Dashboard on Elimination of Single Use Plastic and Plastic Waste Management: India launched a nationwide awareness campaign on Single Use Plastics on World Environment Day in June 2022. A mobile app for Single Use Plastics Grievance Redressal was also launched to empower citizens to check sale/usage/manufacturing of SUP in their area and tackle the plastic menace.
THE CONTEXT: Recently, another poxvirus, mpox, has garnered attention due to global outbreaks and its ability to rapidly evolve and infect humans.
EXPLANATION:
Poxviruses have historically posed significant threats to human health, with smallpox being a notorious example.
Smallpox, a devastating disease, highlighted the importance of vaccination and global public health initiatives in combating infectious diseases.
Efforts to administer the smallpox vaccine led to the eventual eradication of the disease, showcasing the power of sustained public health interventions.
Mpox Emergence and Global Outbreak
Mpox, initially known as monkeypox, gained prominence during a global outbreak spanning 2022-2023.
Despite its previous sporadic occurrences, this outbreak marked a significant expansion of mpox infections across 118 countries, prompting the World Health Organization (WHO) to declare it a public health emergency.
The mortality rate of mpox infections ranges from 1-10%, underscoring its potential threat to global health security.
Genomic Insights into Mpox Evolution
Researchers have delved into the genomic structure of mpox viruses to understand their evolutionary dynamics.
The mpox genome, approximately 197 kilobases in size, exhibits unique features that contribute to its adaptability and virulence.
Notably, sections of the genome previously considered less significant were found to play crucial roles in the virus’s ability to transmit between humans.
Mpox viruses employ a mechanism termed “genomic accordion,” characterized by rhythmic expansions and contractions of the genome.
These fluctuations allow the virus to adapt to selective pressures, such as host immune responses, by duplicating or deleting genes.
Such genomic plasticity enables mpox viruses to evolve rapidly and evade host defenses.
Impact of Clades on Virulence
Mpox viruses are categorized into distinct clades, each associated with varying levels of virulence and transmissibility.
Clade IIb, identified during the 2022 outbreak, demonstrated heightened human-to-human transmission, highlighting the importance of genomic variations in viral adaptation.
Recent Outbreak in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC)
A significant mpox outbreak occurred in the DRC between September 2023 and February 2024, with distinct genomic features associated with increased mortality and human-to-human transmission.
This outbreak underscored the ongoing threat posed by mpox and the need for vigilant surveillance and intervention strategies.
Genomic Surveillance for Disease Prevention
Genomic sequencing plays a crucial role in monitoring and understanding the spread of mpox viruses.
By analyzing viral genomes, researchers can track evolutionary changes and identify emerging lineages associated with increased transmission and virulence.
Such insights inform public health interventions aimed at preventing and controlling outbreaks on a global scale.
Clade:
A clade is a group of organisms that includes an ancestor and all its descendants.
In the case of the Monkeypox virus (MPXV), it is categorized into two main clades: Clade I and Clade II, with Clade II further divided into Clade IIa and Clade IIb.
It has been identified that only Clade I MPXV has been found in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC)
Clade Classification:
Mpox virus (MPXV) is categorized into Clade I and Clade II (further divided into Clade IIa and Clade IIb).
Only Clade I MPXV has been identified in the DRC.
Sexual Transmission of Clade I:
Before April 2023, no documented cases of sexual transmission involving Clade I MPXV existed globally.
However, the report highlighted the first-ever confirmed case of sexual transmission in March 2023, originating from a Belgian traveler in Kwango province and spreading through sexual contacts within the DRC.
Viral sequences showed a close genetic relationship among cases.
MPox:
Mpox (monkeypox) is a viral illness caused by the monkeypox virus, a species of the genus Orthopoxvirus. Two different clades exist: clade I and clade II.
Common symptoms of mpox are a skin rash or mucosal lesions which can last 2–4 weeks accompanied by fever, headache, muscle aches, back pain, low energy, and swollen lymph nodes.
Mpox can be transmitted to humans through physical contact with someone who is infectious, with contaminated materials, or with infected animals.
Laboratory confirmation of mpox is done by testing skin lesion material by PCR.
Mpox is treated with supportive care. Vaccines and therapeutics developed for smallpox and approved for use in some countries can be used for mpox in some circumstances.
In 2022–2023 a global outbreak of mpox was caused by a strain known as clade IIb.
Mpox can be prevented by avoiding physical contact with someone who has mpox. Vaccination can help prevent infection for people at risk.
THE CONTEXT: The Union Health Ministry of India has recently issued a comprehensive directive aimed at enhancing the regulation of organ transplants within the country.
EXPLANATION:
This directive is a response to growing concerns over malpractice and the commercialization of organ transplants, particularly involving foreign nationals.
This ID will be generated by hospitals through the NOTTO website, ensuring a standardized and traceable system for monitoring transplant cases.
The directive explicitly aims to eliminate commercial dealings in organs, especially those involving foreign citizens.
This step is crucial in safeguarding the ethical principles of organ donation and transplantation, prioritizing altruism over financial gain.
To ensure compliance with regulations and to curb any illegal activities, the Ministry calls for stricter monitoring of organ transplants by local authorities.
In addition to deceased donor transplants, the directive emphasizes the importance of regulating living donor transplants.
NOTTO-ID must be generated for both donors and recipients within 48 hours post-surgery, enabling efficient tracking and allocation of organs.
Quality Assurance and Inspection
The Ministry highlights the need for regular inspection of registered hospitals conducting organ transplants.
State authorities are required to monitor these hospitals on-site to ensure the quality of transplantation, post-operative follow-up, and overall outcomes.
Any violations of THOTA, 1994, and its rules are subject to investigation, with potential consequences including the suspension of registration for performing organ transplants.
Data Collection and Sharing
Efficient data collection and sharing are vital for effective regulation and oversight.
The Ministry emphasizes the importance of states regularly sharing data related to organ donation and transplantation with NOTTO.
This ensures comprehensive monitoring and enables informed decision-making at the national level.
Regulation of Foreign Nationals
Special provisions within THOTA, 1994, govern organ transplants involving foreign nationals.
Prior approval from the authorization committee is required for such transplants, along with certification of the relationship between the donor and recipient by senior embassy officials.
These measures aim to verify the authenticity of documents, prevent commercial exploitation, and ensure that donations are made out of genuine altruism.
Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act (THOTA), 1994:
The Transplantation of Human Organs Act (THOA), 1994 was enacted in the year 1994 and has been adopted in all States except erstwhile State of J&K and Andhra Pradesh which have their own legislation in this regard.
Main purpose of the Act is to regulate the removal, storage and transplantation of human organs for therapeutic purposes and for the prevention of commercial dealings in human organs.
The Act was amended in 2011 and the Transplantation of Human Organs (Amendment) Act 2011, has come into force on 10-1-2014 in the States of Goa, Himachal Pradesh, West Bengal, and Union Territories.
Other States who have adopted the amendment Act till date are Rajasthan, Sikkim, Jharkhand, Kerala, Orissa, Punjab, Maharashtra, Assam, Haryana, Manipur, Gujarat, Bihar and Uttar 2 Pradesh. The amended Act is now named Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act (THOTA), 1994.
Brain Stem death is recognized as a legal death in India under the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, since 1994 like many other countries, which has revolutionized the concept of organ donation after death.
After natural cardiac death only a few organs/tissues can be donated (like cornea, bone, skin and blood vessels) whereas after brain stem death almost 37 different organs and tissues can be donated including vital organs such as kidneys, heart, liver and lungs.
National Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation (NOTTO):
This has been mandated as per the Transplantation of Human Organs (Amendment) Act 2011.
National Network division of NOTTO would function as apex centre for All India activities of coordination and networking for procurement and distribution of Organs and Tissues and registry of Organs and Tissues Donation and Transplantation in the country.
